First glance appearance/personality traits, and you're hooked, so far

[AGDee]

Yeah, once you eliminated the face as an option, I have nothing. It's all about eyes (need to be laughing eyes, sparkly) and smile (easy, full face). It doesn't matter what color the eyes are, or the shape, it's that the windows are the eyes to the soul and a man who can express himself with only his eyes will catch my attention every time.