Recs aren't [are!] necessary

[Titchou]

MysticCat: You asked why PNMs can't be told that SOME groups require recs. That is the question I was answering...not whether recs are required for the campus. That is an entirely different question. There is nothing in the rules that keep a CPH from telling PNMs that SOME groups require recs but they cannot tell them the namesof the ones that do...nor can they say it's requiredfor the whole campus.
I only know what you say, not what you mean to say.

[Drolefille]

Originally Posted by Titchou

MysticCat: You asked why PNMs can't be told that SOME groups require recs. That is the question I was answering...not whether recs are required for the campus. That is an entirely different question. There is nothing in the rules that keep a CPH from telling PNMs that SOME groups require recs but they cannot tell them the namesof the ones that do...nor can they say it's requiredfor the whole campus.
I only know what you say, not what you mean to say.

I have no idea what you're saying here. And like MC I don't know how you thought he was asking about anything that could get close to MS.

But the more we discuss it the less clear it gets.