American Idol Season 8

[LΩVE]

Originally Posted by Tippiechick

No. Her voice is fundamentally NOT good. You shouldn't have to move your head to control your vocal movements. Moving her head was the only way she could do the runs and even then she missed notes and sounded off in places.

Just. Not. Good. And. Thinks. Her. Body. Should. Buy. Her. Way. In.

And, I guess it just did.

I'm not musical, so it sounded good to me, honestly. Kara's was better though. I always hate it when the contestants try to tell the judges something. They're judges because they've already made it. You're a contestant because you haven't.

[Tippiechick]

Originally Posted by LΩVE

I'm not musical, so it sounded good to me, honestly. Kara's was better though. I always hate it when the contestants try to tell the judges something. They're judges because they've already made it. You're a contestant because you haven't.

My husband said, "It sounded really good to me."

[LΩVE]

Originally Posted by Tippiechick

My husband said, "It sounded really good to me."

Haha. My boyfriend would've too if he watched it. I don't know anything about techniques, I just thought it sounded pretty decent to me. They didn't show many that were really amazing, so I guess there wasn't a lot to compare her to.