THANK YOU for these beautiful options! I didn't realize Pi Phi had a store on their website. My eye is so trained for blue & blue and fleur-de-lis, I can't just spot cute options at the craft store. I'm so happy to support my new Monmouth Duo sister.
ETA: some non-cheesy and different ideas I found:
adorable baseball-style T
http://t-shirts.cafepress.com/item/p...raglan/9639858
tote bag with embroidery
http://www.almostdemure.com/pibephitobag.html
different kind of key chain
http://somethinggreek.com/shop/shope...ychain&id=2970
and I LOVE stationary
http://www.erincondren.com/store/pro...roducts_id=664
Hybrid Mode
