How to help PNMs who don't get first choice?

[KSUViolet06]

Something to think about: In some situations, the disparity in the PNMs mind between their two choices isn't always so serious that she is devastated when she gets her 2nd choice. Like the PNM ranks ABC first and XYZ second, but isn't upset when she gets XYZ because she still likes them. I could possibly see a PNM being devastated over getting a 3rd choice, but not a 2nd.

I'm not the biggest advocate for this, but I personally think that if you would rather not be in a sorority at all than be in your 2nd choice OR it's so serious that you're going to need counseling or be depressed about getting a bid there--you should just ISP (intentional single pref or "suicide").

[1908Revelations]

Originally Posted by adpiucf

I really think it is an issue that the new member needs to learn to handle on her own. It may be disappointing to not receive your first choice bid. However, at the risk of sounding cynical: that's life. The sooner you figure out you're not always going to get 100% of what you want when you want it, the better.

I'm cynical, yes. But these girls need to grow up sometime.

Originally Posted by KSUViolet06

I totally agree. So you got your 2nd choice? Okay. You could've NOT gotten a bid at all. You should just be excited that these people are happy to have you and enojy your new member period. If you find that you can't do that, deplede and don't continue to waste the sorority's time and yours.

Excuse the crash, but I like what KSUViolet said as well as adpiucf.

Correct me if I am wrong, but on the pref card one should put Sororities that they actucally see themselves belonging to rather than fill up the card and see what you get, right? If that is the case someone getting their second choice should not be a big beal and if they didn't want them they had the choice to suicide, right?

Like KSU said, they better be happy they get in a house because some girls don't get picked at all.


ETA:
For example I have heard some interested girls (NPHC) talk about if they have to join on a line that is large they would rather wait or not join at all. I call BS on that because if they want the Sorority for the right reasons they would not care about that moretheless they should think about how many people wish they could get in. I swear people are such babies. There are many other women who would be glad to be in ABC, XYZ, 123 so shut up! LOL

[33girl]

Originally Posted by Zillini

I've seen PNMs/new members announce at their new house during the Bid Day celebration that they didn't get their 1st choice. I've seen PNMs in tears having to be talked into putting a jersey on. Not the best way to start off one's membership even if it does end up working out for the best in the long run.

oooh, yipes, no, bad plan.

Originally Posted by 1908Revelations

Excuse the crash, but I like what KSUViolet said as well as adpiucf.

Correct me if I am wrong, but on the pref card one should put Sororities that they actucally see themselves belonging to rather than fill up the card and see what you get, right? If that is the case someone getting their second choice should not be a big deal and if they didn't want them they had the choice to suicide, right?

Like KSU said, they better be happy they get in a house because some girls don't get picked at all.

I forget if this is a school rule or an NPC rule, but if you suicide/don't pref the max available you aren't eligible for snap bids. Then again, if you would take a snap bid from someone, you should put them on your list....it's just an issue of your not ranking them highly enough. (I hope that makes sense.)

Plus, don't some computer programs "kick out" women who suicide, or is that a myth?

[KSUViolet06]

Originally Posted by 33girl

Plus, don't some computer programs "kick out" women who suicide, or is that a myth?

This is a myth. ICS (the major computer recruitment program most schools use) does not do this.

[violetpretty]

It's just that women who suicide aren't eligible to be QAs. I can see where the myth comes from, though. It's easier to tell a PNM that the computer might reduce your chances of getting a bid if you suicide instead of trying to explain how bid matching and quota additions work.

[jwright25]

Originally Posted by 33girl

I forget if this is a school rule or an NPC rule, but if you suicide/don't pref the max available you aren't eligible for snap bids. Then again, if you would take a snap bid from someone, you should put them on your list....it's just an issue of your not ranking them highly enough. (I hope that makes sense.)

The NPC rule applies to ISP'ers being ineligible for Quota Additions. But it doesn't cover snap bidding. Technically, if a woman suicides and doesn't match, she is just unmatched and therefore eligible for snap bidding and/or COR. However, some schools may take that rule on out as you suggested, making ISP'ers ineligible for snap bidding.

Originally Posted by 33girl

Plus, don't some computer programs "kick out" women who suicide, or is that a myth?

ICS doesn't and Campus Director (Innova) doesn't. But I'm not familiar with any others.

[33girl]

Originally Posted by jwright25

The NPC rule applies to ISP'ers being ineligible for Quota Additions. But it doesn't cover snap bidding. Technically, if a woman suicides and doesn't match, she is just unmatched and therefore eligible for snap bidding and/or COR. However, some schools may take that rule on out as you suggested, making ISP'ers ineligible for snap bidding.

Thanks for the clarification...it was all just "open bid" back in the day.

[UGAalum94]

If you don't really want your second and third choice, you probably shouldn't try to be a quota addition since there's no guarantee that you'll be a QA at the one chapter you like.

I think I would just have the recruitment counselors emphasize as much as possible that you can be matched to any group you list on the card. Have them talk about it several times throughout the process. Be honest and admit that leaving a chapter off the bid card doesn't affect your chances of getting a bid at the ones you do list if you really don't want the chapter you leave off.

My opinion may be biased by looking at the stats from the couple of campuses that release them to the public, but it seems like arranging bid events or bid card practices around the relatively small number of girls who don't get what they want is kind of a downer for everyone. It ought to be the case that we can assume that if the PNM listed the chapter, then she's happy that she matched. Let the celebration begin!

Sure, she may not think she's as happy as if she got her number one, but why approach things like "are you going be okay with this bid?' rather than "yea, you got this bid!" if the girl really can't do much about it anyway?