I haven't seen Moonlight Mile yet but I love Jake Gyllenhaal. He was in the Good Girl with Jennifer Aniston and Donnie Darko, which I highly recommend. And oh yeah, he did the remake of the Boy in the Plastic Bubble movie.
I don't think he's classically good looking, though he does have these great blue eyes. It's more that he comes off as intelligent but offbeat, funny and sensitive... which I love.
Rent the Donnie Darko DVD then listen to his commentary track with the director. He does this great Christopher Walken impression.
I can't wait to see this . . . and yes, I think Jake Gyllenhaal is attractive. I saw him first in The Good Girl and then in Donny Darko, both of which are recommended . . . good stuff.