American Idol 7

[PrettyInPink777]

Originally Posted by RBL

The final 3 SHOULD be... Syesha, David A and David C.......
Syesha could come out next week like Tina Turner and kill it and she will be in the Bottom 2 and the judges will find something wrong..while David A could sneeze and the judges will call it BRILLIANT.. she's fighting for 3rd.. it has to be frustrating to know that someone like Jason is getting by on charm and SUPER WEAK Vocals....

Are you psychic???

[RBL]

Originally Posted by PrettyInPink777

Are you psychic???

ROTFL......

[RBL]

Even though I think this years Top 12 were talented in someway or another (maybe except Jason.. I just dont get this dude).. this has been one of the worst seasons EVER

[nittanyalum]

I do not get what Simon has against Syesha.

I swear, if he fawns all over Castro, I'll throw my shoe at the TV.

[nittanyalum]

Don't read srmom --

I'm beyond giddy that Castro is crashing and burning.

HOW do you forget THE CHORUS? Buh-bye.

[tinydancer]

Originally Posted by nittanyalum

Don't read srmom --

I'm beyond giddy that Castro is crashing and burning.

HOW do you forget THE CHORUS? Buh-bye.

That was just one hot mess!

[PM_Mama00]

Originally Posted by nittanyalum

Don't read srmom --

I'm beyond giddy that Castro is crashing and burning.

HOW do you forget THE CHORUS? Buh-bye.

What's he on? Is he getting high before every performance? Those are some glossy ass eyes.

[RBL]

David C- sounds the same pretty much.. I liked both songs alright

Syesha- loved both performances.. I wish on the Sam Cooke song she had stripped the arrangement down or sung it acapella.. her tears at the end should get her (deservedly) to the Top 3. Her first song was a tad copycat-ish but she performed well

Jason- I have no words.. he should have been gone.. I HATE him

David A.. boy the tongue bath was in effect tonight.. undeservedly. His first song.. sorry but Stand By Me is a SOUL classic regardless of the arrangement SOUL is essential and while he sung it well he had not a lick of soul and I think he failed. The second song was all cheese and that falsetto he has is horrid. Again I think he sung it ok but I just didnt care..which means he'll probably win..lol

[kddani]

My fiance and I were cracking up when David A. sung. With the microphone clutched firmly in the left hand and his right hand out begging for votes, we were reminded of this:

[Thetagirl218]

Originally Posted by kddani

kddani, You just made my night! LMAO!

On another note, I haven't watched tonight's show yet, but I cannot say I really want to.....I am sooo bored this season!

[a.e.B.O.T.]

Simon has, in the past, said he misjudged the contestant and noticed he was wrong when he went back and watched them on the tele. He has even said that visa versa, that they were worse on the tele. This might be a time for Randy to say the same thing, because Syesha was pitch perfect on her second song, although the performance was conventional and tired. That performance shows that she has the best vocal range on the show. What she does not have that the davids have is an original voice, a huge fan base, and a spark that makes her seem beyond human. I don't think she is this years American Idol, but I really hope she beats out Castro this round. Fair is fair, and out of the four, she deserves to be in the final three in comparison to hippie boy.

[PrettyInPink777]

^^^^^ Darn, you're good !! heehee

[PrettyInPink777]

I must say I actively detest the corn-pone arrangements and choreography that the AI contestants are forced to perform. How embarrassed they must be! (especially David Cook!!)

[ComradesTrue]

America got it right. Finally.

[Leslie Anne]

YES!