I wrote a response to this twice today and both times my browser froze. Crappin-ass-crappin' Vista. Here's attempt #3:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blondie93
But, I must give my props to nittanyalum... she called it long before I did. Here goes: Brooke- I am just starting to find you annoying. Please stop talking.
|
I knew there was a reason I liked you!
I just can't even start on Brooke, so I won't. But I too was concerned with the fashion choices and I would toss Carly on that pile. I thought she looked horrid and I almost fell over when Simon actually complimented her. My husband and I both commented that she just looked angry and MEAN when she sang (and butchered the song - she can't come close to Freddy Mercury). My husband also commented on Paula's boobs. More than once. And not in a flattering way. And I agree that David C. chose a bad song, although I think he still did pretty well. What I wish he had thought about twice was that writing "Give back" on his hand. Height of cheesiness. The only ones who could maybe, MAYBE pull that off are Michael Stipe and Bono. But even though he's my fave, that made me cringe.
Quote:
|
It seems like last year they did not kick anyone off the week of Idol Gives Back. I don't feel like counting weeks left in the season to see if the same will be true this week. However, if there are any anal-retentive folks out there who are up for figuring that out, please pass it on!
|
My earlier response was that this is what I recall too and I thought they just added this week's votes to next week's votes and then kicked off based on the total. But I've since seen the show and now we know there's a special episode tomorrow night and someone is getting sent home.
Quote:
|
if KLC is somehow spared a bottom-dwelling spot this week, would the producers PLEASE let her know this early on, so that she can enjoy her week on the couch? Never once has the poor girl been able to spend any relaxing time over there!!!
|
I co-sign on this, the girl deserves a break, and I thought she was great this week! And I don't understand why the teen boys aren't voting for her in droves? I think she's adorable. I agree with Brooke and Carly in the bottom 3 (of course
), but I would put Michael Johns in (*gasp* blasphemy! I know!) instead of Syesha. I like Syesha and I thought she sang the bejebus out of that song, even though I don't care for that song (all the "winner" songs have always been so painful). Michael has got to get over this singing 70s rock songs, it is not his thing and I thought he sounded terrible last night. I would like to see Brooke get the bootage. Or Carly. Or Brooke.
Quote:
Originally Posted by a.e.B.O.T.
gave the win to Castro. He was amazing!
|
I can't even begin to tell you how much it pains me to say this, but ugh, co-sign, Castro did well last night. Dang it.
I missed the very beginning of tonight's show, but I cried buckets watching the rest of it (must be the Social Justice Crusader in me). Annie Lennox's film piece and then her song just about did me in and Carrie Underwood was amazing singing that George Michaels song (which I've always loved).
). 
Hybrid Mode
