Quote:
Originally posted by MysticCat81
I've got a feeling we haven't seen the last of Snuffles.
|
I have to agree with you. Do we really know what is beyond the veil? Luna and Harry heard voices there. Is he really dead? I just reread that whole scene. First off when Harry tells Lupin they can still reach Sirius, Lupin says "There's nothing you can do, Harry....nothing...He's gone."
Harry keeps calling for Sirius so Lupin says "He can't come back, because he's d____" Harry yells "He's not dead" before Lupin can finish what he was going to say - so is he really dead or was it something else Lupin was going to say.
When Harry spoke to Nick about being a ghost notice that Nick never said Sirius was dead. "...when somebody has suffered a .... loss"
(notice the pause before the word loss) and then he tells Harry "He will not come back. He will have....gone on"
From what I can tell only Harry has used the word dead and die when talking about what happened to Sirius.
Just putting forth another possibility,
Carolyn
Carolyn
Hybrid Mode
