Maryland Boy Learns Lesson With "Homeless" Sign Punishment

[DrPhil]

Originally Posted by TonyB06

I think it's terrible that people resort to doing this kind of foolishness to their children in the name of "teaching them a lesson."

I agree. These parents are attention whores who want their public "lessons" to be showcased on facebook, youtube, Greekchat (), Good Morning America, etc.

A better lesson is to have your child volunteer at a homeless shelter and meet homeless children. That is if homelessness is truly the lesson. Perhaps being made to come home and not get to visit a friend's house for a few months is a more immediate and logical lesson for this "offense".

[MysticCat]

Originally Posted by DrPhil

I agree. These parents are attention whores who want their public "lessons" to be showcased on facebook, youtube, Greekchat (), Good Morning America, etc.

A better lesson is to have your child volunteer at a homeless shelter and meet homeless children. That is if homelessness is truly the lesson. Perhaps being made to come home and not get to visit a friend's house for a few months is a more immediate and logical lesson for this "offense".

I agree as well. Terrible parenting in my view.

We've always taken the view that the punishment should fit the crime. The "crime" is failing to check in. Grounding seems to fit much better for that. Meanwhile Dad says he wants to teach respect. I fail to see how public embarrassment teaches respect.

[AlphaFrog]

Originally Posted by DrPhil

I agree. These parents are attention whores who want their public "lessons" to be showcased on facebook, youtube, Greekchat (), Good Morning America, etc.

A better lesson is to have your child volunteer at a homeless shelter and meet homeless children. That is if homelessness is truly the lesson. Perhaps being made to come home and not get to visit a friend's house for a few months is a more immediate and logical lesson for this "offense".

All of this. He's actually making light of homelessness, which is the OPPOSITE of what he says he's doing.

[Munchkin03]

If you see the comments, the father has chimed in. He misquotes Bernie Mac, uses all sorts of cliches, and doesn't know the difference between "know" and "no." Not only did he have a great big parenting FAIL, he sounds like a blooming idiot.

I liked his explanation as to why he just didn't ground the kid/take away his electronics: after all the time it would take to remove the TV, Playstation, etc., and ground him for a week, it wouldn't be worth it. What does this kid have, a man cave?

[AGDee]

Originally Posted by MysticCat

I agree as well. Terrible parenting in my view.

We've always taken the view that the punishment should fit the crime. The "crime" is failing to check in. Grounding seems to fit much better for that. Meanwhile Dad says he wants to teach respect. I fail to see how public embarrassment teaches respect.

I agree.

Originally Posted by Munchkin03

If you see the comments, the father has chimed in. He misquotes Bernie Mac, uses all sorts of cliches, and doesn't know the difference between "know" and "no." Not only did he have a great big parenting FAIL, he sounds like a blooming idiot.

I liked his explanation as to why he just didn't ground the kid/take away his electronics: after all the time it would take to remove the TV, Playstation, etc., and ground him for a week, it wouldn't be worth it. What does this kid have, a man cave?

Meh, my kids have that stuff too and most kids that age have that stuff now. My coworker was smart with this stuff. She just took all the power cords to things when she was grounding her kids. You don't have to move everything out, you just have to make them not function. When her kids were doing things on the Internet when grounded, she took the power cord to the cable modem to work with her. Problem solved.

[Munchkin03]

Originally Posted by AGDee

Meh, my kids have that stuff too and most kids that age have that stuff now. My coworker was smart with this stuff. She just took all the power cords to things when she was grounding her kids. You don't have to move everything out, you just have to make them not function. When her kids were doing things on the Internet when grounded, she took the power cord to the cable modem to work with her. Problem solved.

Whether kids today have that stuff isn't the issue. My issue is that he thought actually taking it away, or even disconnecting the stuff, was too much of an inconvenience. Publicly humiliating his son, however, was more convenient.

How long would it take to disconnect the games/computers and put them away? An hour?

[33girl]

Originally Posted by Munchkin03

Whether kids today have that stuff isn't the issue. My issue is that he thought actually taking it away, or even disconnecting the stuff, was too much of an inconvenience. Publicly humiliating his son, however, was more convenient.

How long would it take to disconnect the games/computers and put them away? An hour?

It takes longer if you are stupid.

[AGDee]

Originally Posted by Munchkin03

Whether kids today have that stuff isn't the issue. My issue is that he thought actually taking it away, or even disconnecting the stuff, was too much of an inconvenience. Publicly humiliating his son, however, was more convenient.

How long would it take to disconnect the games/computers and put them away? An hour?

I was in agreement with you on that part and was pointing out that all you really have to take away are the power cords. You don't have to physically remove anything else. You just have to make it useless.

[christiangirl]

Originally Posted by Munchkin03

How long would it take to disconnect the games/computers and put them away? An hour?

When the kid I was sitting for threw a fit over the Xbox, it took me approx. 20 seconds to unplug it and put it away. Doing what Dee said and taking the power cord would have been about 5.

Originally Posted by DrPhil

A better lesson is to have your child volunteer at a homeless shelter and meet homeless children.

I've heard of this being done in a few different instances and, in each one, the teens learned nothing. I find that kids can be pretty short-sighted. Honestly, sacrifice has to be freely given for it to mean anything. If it's done by force, the message is totally lost in a lot of cases.