American Idol - Season 10

[ASTalumna06]

*loving James again*

He had one off night last week, but he's back on track to winning the whole damn thing.

After tonight, I REALLY hope Haley goes home. I haven't been too thrilled with her from the beginning, even though she's definitely gotten better week after week. But her attitude with the judges tonight completely turned me off.

You just don't pull that kind of stuff a couple weeks before the finale.

[txpacer]

Originally Posted by ASTalumna06

*loving James again*


After tonight, I REALLY hope Haley goes home. I haven't been too thrilled with her from the beginning, even though she's definitely gotten better week after week. But her attitude with the judges tonight completely turned me off.

You just don't pull that kind of stuff a couple weeks before the finale.

I disagree. If the judges were saying all of that to me in front of millions of people, basically telling me that I wasn't really in the competition anymore, I would be pretty steamed, too.

[ASTalumna06]

Originally Posted by txpacer

I disagree. If the judges were saying all of that to me in front of millions of people, basically telling me that I wasn't really in the competition anymore, I would be pretty steamed, too.

Defending yourself is one thing. Talking over the judges and coming incredibly close to rolling your eyes at everything they said throughout the rest of the night, is another.

On top of that, they told her last week to pick a more well-known song. She clearly ignored that. That's her prerogative, but she shouldn't have been surprised when the judges told her the same thing again this week.

Also, she didn't sound as good as the other 3. Plain and simple. I'm just glad that the judges (well, Randy and J Lo, anyway) were finally able to speak the truth and tell someone how they really felt!