So You Think You Can Dance: Season 5

[LeslieAGD]

I was (pleasantly) surprised that Caitlyn and Jason weren't in the bottom. I think it was good to see Jeanine perform a solo...she's excellent on her own, and not just pulling votes as "Phillip's partner."

I still don't understand why the judges like Kayla so much. In fact, I am really starting to dislike her now. Both times she's been in the bottom the judges have told her that her solo is nowhere near good enough, and yet they CONTINUE to fawn over her. GAG!!!

[ASTalumna06]

Originally Posted by LeslieAGD

I was (pleasantly) surprised that Caitlyn and Jason weren't in the bottom. I think it was good to see Jeanine perform a solo...she's excellent on her own, and not just pulling votes as "Phillip's partner."

I still don't understand why the judges like Kayla so much. In fact, I am really starting to dislike her now. Both times she's been in the bottom the judges have told her that her solo is nowhere near good enough, and yet they CONTINUE to fawn over her. GAG!!!

I'm also happy that Jeanine was able to perform a solo. I'm sure that having Phillip as her partner has been difficult. He doesn't have a good understanding of most types of dance, which can make her look bad as part of the couple.. and he tends to overshadow her in the hip hop routines (even though she does exceptionally well, especially considering it's not "her style").

And I completely agree with your second point. This is what made me question last night why they "dance for their lives." There seems to be no point if those dances have no bearing on the judges decision.

[bostongreek]

Originally Posted by LeslieAGD

I was (pleasantly) surprised that Caitlyn and Jason weren't in the bottom. I think it was good to see Jeanine perform a solo...she's excellent on her own, and not just pulling votes as "Phillip's partner."

I still don't understand why the judges like Kayla so much. In fact, I am really starting to dislike her now. Both times she's been in the bottom the judges have told her that her solo is nowhere near good enough, and yet they CONTINUE to fawn over her. GAG!!!

Kayla and Kupono shouldn't have been in the bottom 3 last night based on their Tuesday night performance... I think that the judges take more into account than just their solo when making a decision.

That said, I think the entire B3 was wrong, wrong, wrong last night!

[LeslieAGD]

Originally Posted by bostongreek

That said, I think the entire B3 was wrong, wrong, wrong last night!

Who would you have put in the bottom?

Like I said earlier, I though C&J would have been there instead of Phillip/Jeanine, but other than that I thought it was right.

[bostongreek]

Originally Posted by LeslieAGD

Who would you have put in the bottom?

Like I said earlier, I though C&J would have been there instead of Phillip/Jeanine, but other than that I thought it was right.

I agreed with Vitolio and Carla, but I think the other two should have been Caitlin and Jason and Randi and Evan. Evan's fanbase is insaneee, it would have been absolute B3 for anyone but him.