Quote:
Originally Posted by Munchkin03
I agree: I think I'm beyond bugged and it gets to be offensive. The person just ends up becoming a token.
I think well-intentioned liberals, egged on by the mainstream media, can't be faced with a liberal Black or Latino overachiever without putting the "up from the ghetto/barrio/sharecropper" story on them, whether or not it's true. When it's true, as seems to be the case with Sotomayor, I feel like it almost diminishes her accomplishments because her whole life story is condensed to that sound bite. When it's only slightly true, in the case of our President, it seems as if liberals and the mainstream media can't stomach the idea of a successful black or Hispanic person who came from an educated middle-class background. When it can't be applied at all, or if the politics of the person in general don't fit in with the mainstream media (case in point: Condolleezza Rice), it's not seen as an accomplishment at all. It's been annoying me for a little while now, and maybe the conservative press does it as well, so I'm just sensitive to it.
|
I probably wouldn't have said exactly that the media can't stomach the idea of successful black or Hispanic people with middle class backgrounds, but I agree that they oversell the up from nothing background story when the person's politics is correct. If you are conservative, forget it; it's just assumed that your were middle class or rich, it seems to me.
On the one hand, I'm a fan of giving Black and Hispanic kids successful people of originally meager means and similar ethnicity to look up to. On the other hand, why the love affair with people starting out poor? Sure, it's great when people overcome adversity, but how many of us are really born with silver spoons in our mouths? How many people in the last 50 years got to the level of Supreme Court nominee without having sincere personal accomplishments, Harriet Miers excepted?
I'd also, like those of you who've already said so, like to see people promoted and evaluated based on their accomplishments. I find the idea of using identity and ability for empathy kind of troubling standards in the judicial system, but Obama's been pretty open about using them.
Threaded Mode
