American Idol 7

[PeppyGPhiB]

Originally Posted by GPhiBLtColonel

David A is NOT marketable IMHO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! blech!

I agree. The little girls may like him right now, but I think it's because they think he's cute. If you took away his visual appeal, I don't think his song choices have any appeal to the youngins, and his voice is not a big deal to adults...plus I think most adults would feel creeped out being a fan of a 16 year old boy. Bottom line: I think he's another Taylor Hicks...they like him now, but they're not gonna buy his records.

[a.e.B.O.T.]

Originally Posted by PeppyGPhiB

f you took away his visual appeal, I don't think his song choices have any appeal to the youngins, and his voice is not a big deal to adults...

Visual Appeal? Visual Appeal? I have took dumps that had better faces. However, he is charming and some may say endearing, and his song choices help that, cuz here is a little kid singing about world peace or the ultimate love. Kids and idealism works! His voice on the other hand, not so much. AND, hopefully his voice isnt done developing, cuz if he sounds like that at 25, he will never get laid