Leave it to some Beatles songs to separate the wheat from the chaffe. Interesting night.
My top tier for the night:
Chikezie - Huge kudos! That was pure joy.
David Cook - Great. Really powerful. I had no idea he was sweet and humble too.
Carly - Of the rocker chicks, I liked her the best. Something about her annoys me but she sure can sing and command a stage.
Brooke - Solid.
Middle tier:
Aussie Man - I LOVE his voice but he played it way too safe. He's capable of much more.
Amanda - I don't know why but I just want to deck her. Yeah, she has a good voice but you can tell for a fact that she's watched
The Rose and thinks she's Janis Joplin reincarnated.

Let me tell you, girl, both Janis Joplin and Bette Midler could vocally kick your Harley-riding ass!
Ramiele - Another person with a great voice who's playing it safe. Too soon to tell if she can pull it off.
Bottom tier:
David Archuleta - Huge screw-up last night. You'd think with his experience he'd make sure he knows his lyrics.
Syesha Mercado - Great voice but she seemed
so uncomfortable on stage.
David Hernandez - Cheeeeessseeeeeeey.
Jason Castro - I finally figured out who he reminds me of, Tiny Tim with a bit of really bad Cat Stevens. Can't wait for him to get the boot.
Kristy Lee - PAINFUL