Quote:
Originally Posted by SigmaChiCard
I agree that most of these are great, but honestly I believe Panda Bear is terrible...I feel that people like to think he's good more than anyone actually likes him...the same way most people are with Pere Ubu. SMD was a great one as was Burial.
|
Well, from your blog post, it seems like you're also down on
Strawberry Jam and
Let's Stay Friends, two albums that would have been in the 20-25 range on my list this year - it's likely a difference in taste more than anything, so there's really not going to be much in the way of discussion here.
However, I'll tell you that "Bros" isn't the singular work of genius Pitchfork et al. would have you believe - I personally don't find it to be the best song on the album, even. However, I find
Person Pitch a remarkably rewarding listen, sort of a complex version of Brian Wilson's work with a sort of Brian Eno vibe. It's not like the lyrics would win a Pulitzer if written on the page, but I don't particularly care if the music works well.
It was kind of a grower for me, though - sort of the opposite of the SMD album, really, in that I like it a LOT more after many spins that I did at first blush (whereas SMD's early singles blew me away, and A/D/S/R was almost a letdown when finally released).
Finally, you may be right that Panda Bear benefits in the press from his Animal Collective ties, as I think AC is one of the most overrated bands out there in general (
Strawberry Jam was their first album I actually really enjoy on any level, and
Sung Tongs makes me wish I was just listening to Man Man and cutting out the middle man), but I can tell you from my point of view that
Person Pitch is considerably better than any of the Animal Collective work, so I can't really chalk it up to nuthugging either. YMMV apparently.