I may be the oddball here, but I couldn't care less how many girls a guy has had sex with. Clearly there is the health issue associated with sex, so I would want them to use protection and get tested...but otherwise I don't really see what it has to do with me if he's with me at this point. I've dated guys on both sides of the "numbers" spectrum and I don't think you can judge someone based on their magic number.
However, that being said...I really don't want to date some guy who is not at all particular about who he sleeps with and just sticks his weiner wherever there's a female within range. That would bother me more than a guy who has just dated a lot and slept with the girls he's dated. To be honest, I would actually prefer a guy who's gotten all of that out of his system before he met me.
Threaded Mode