Bravo's Top Chef New York

[epchick]

Originally Posted by Kappamd

WHAT JUST HAPPENED?!?!?!?!?!

I know!!! lol.


I knew when Carla said she was gonna to not do the tart and listen to Kasey's suggestion of the souffle that she was not gonna win. But to totally discount her at the end I don't feel was right. I still think the discussion of the winner should have included Carla instead of saying "well, I guess we agree Carla's out." Her explanation of why she should be Top Chef was enough for me to vote for her! lol. It looked like she got Stefan all teary too.

[VandalSquirrel]

It isn't on here for another two hours. But I guess I don't have to watch it now.

[ASUADPi]

I am just glad Stefan didn't win. Me personally, I would never go to a restuarant owned by him. I'm much rather go to one owed by Hosea or Carla. I much prefer Carla.

I too thought it was a little, cheap, of the judges to say that Carla was out because her last course didn't have a souffle (however you spell it). They should have taken in account the whole season (on all the contestants), not just the final challenge.

Whatever, Stefan didn't win, I'm happy.

[SATX*APhi]

Originally Posted by ASUADPi

I am just glad Stefan didn't win. Me personally, I would never go to a restuarant owned by him. I'm much rather go to one owed by Hosea or Carla. I much prefer Carla.

I too thought it was a little, cheap, of the judges to say that Carla was out because her last course didn't have a souffle (however you spell it). They should have taken in account the whole season (on all the contestants), not just the final challenge.

Whatever, Stefan didn't win, I'm happy.

co-sign

[PeppyGPhiB]

It wasn't just the souffle that nailed Carla...it was the meat dish, too. She let Kasey talk her into doing those things, and it meant Carla was out of her element. As much as I wanted her to win, I knew as soon as she lost the souffle that she was done.

[whiteandblack]

^^^ interesting.

[epchick]

Originally Posted by PeppyGPhiB

It wasn't just the souffle that nailed Carla...it was the meat dish, too. She let Kasey talk her into doing those things, and it meant Carla was out of her element. As much as I wanted her to win, I knew as soon as she lost the souffle that she was done.

I honestly don't know why Carla did that! The pressure of the whole thing must have really gotten to her, enough that she would second guess her own taste.

I knew that once Carla said she was gonna go with Kasey's idea for the souffle that it was over. I don't remember what season Kasey was on, or what she cooked. But I remember her not being that good (right? I could be confusing her with someone). I practically screamed out NOOO CARLA!!!

[OtterXO]

Originally Posted by epchick

I honestly don't know why Carla did that! The pressure of the whole thing must have really gotten to her, enough that she would second guess her own taste.

I knew that once Carla said she was gonna go with Kasey's idea for the souffle that it was over. I don't remember what season Kasey was on, or what she cooked. But I remember her not being that good (right? I could be confusing her with someone). I practically screamed out NOOO CARLA!!!

No, Casey was good. She was in the final three on her season. IIRC she had a tendency to crack under pressure though. I think Carla should have just done what she planned, not been influenced by Casey and she would have won.

I'm just glad Stefan didn't win. He's such an arrogant a-hole. I would have really liked to see Fabio or Carla win though