Harry Potter Speculation

[ZTABullwinkle]

Sunday night I was watching a special about the Harry Potter movies on A&E (it will be repeated on Thursday night at 11 pm if you want to TiVO it.) Something was mentioned about the Room of Requirement in the fifth movie. I thought that Dobby found it for Dumbledore's Army. However, during the show they said that Neville finds the room. Am I remembering it wrong?

[Drolefille]

Originally Posted by ZTABullwinkle

Sunday night I was watching a special about the Harry Potter movies on A&E (it will be repeated on Thursday night at 11 pm if you want to TiVO it.) Something was mentioned about the Room of Requirement in the fifth movie. I thought that Dobby found it for Dumbledore's Army. However, during the show they said that Neville finds the room. Am I remembering it wrong?

You remember right. Dumbledore talks about it with the room full of chamberpots, and I can't remember if it was confirmed that the Mirror of Erised was there (I always thought it was) but Harry doesn't learn about it until Dobby tells him.

A difference in the movie perhaps? There's no house elf plot in the movies so Dobby couldn't be bringing Winky there in the first place...

[AlethiaSi]

hmmm interesting...

Fans Beg JKRowling to keep writing


The petition: save harry

[Drolefille]

She is going to write something like a history. I don't remember which book it is (one of the ones mentioned in the series) but I call it HP's Silmarillion.

[lauralaylin]

It's Hogwarts: A History. I thought she had just said it was a possibility that she would write it, not that it was definite?

[ErinIsBadNews]

Originally Posted by lauralaylin

It's Hogwarts: A History. I thought she had just said it was a possibility that she would write it, not that it was definite?

I think she just said she may do it at some point for charity. (If I remember correctly?)

[carnation]

Newest Harry Potter Quiz: Which Character Are You?

http://familyfun.go.com/parties/kids...html?CMP=NL_Wk

I'm Harry!