|
What if the Carver was Julia?
|
Do you think Christian did something to Rhea's anesthesia to make her suffer for lying?
|
Man I don't even watch this show and yet I make a random guess that the hot guy is the Carver and I am almost right?
My girlyfriend told me about the "scenes from the next NIP TUCK" and how Christian got arrested. Well guess what man. Just because of that, Christian isn't the carver. I wished he was the Carver so all the girls would be like, " oh my gosh I am in love with a pyscho path!". But yeah that is not goign to happen. I guess the Carver is David Hassellhoff then. |
Just watched my tivo'd ep of last night's Nip/Tuck. WOW.
Its Quentin. Voice sounded just like his when he was attacking Rhea. |
Quote:
|
I think the Carver is either Matt or Kimber...they're both wacko enough. I think having the hot new doc being the Carver would be a bitch of stretch, but I suppose anything's possible. I don't think he is though, he's just an asshole (but man, he is so hot!). Cannot WAIT for tomorrow night's episode! :D
|
Ohh only 8 more hours! Am I the only one who watches this show and literally gasps and repeats "OH MY GOD!!!" over and over again?? My roommate cant stand to watch this show because of the surgery scenes, but she can hear whats going on just from my reactions in the next room. I love it.
|
Quote:
|
Holy cow! What a crazy episode! Christian was way smart though, even if you think he did the wrong thing. The ending was just insane.
|
I think the Carver has GOT to be Kimber. How else would that evidence be planted? And it would make sense that she didnt mess up Christians face.. she's the one that would have to look at it.
|
Okay so I hear you, but I'm not so sure anyone aside from Christian can be ruled out, b/c the ONLY one we know for sure it wasn't able to be.
KIMBER- wouldn't that be too obvious? She was a psycho before though, so who knows. But then again, whoever it is, is gonna be in jail and not on the show, and I dunno if they wanna give Kimber up as a character yet. JULIA- If you ask me Julia's def not who we think she is. I mean we know she can cheat on her husband. I'm not saying I think it's her necessarily, but I think there's a lot more to her than is made obvious. LIZ- she was quick to turn on Christian. Which, if I was the Carver, I would do as well. She's def a character that could have seen how to do things surgically. She hears a lot from the guys and knows who to mess with. She's been pissed off by both Christian and Sean. She also cares about beauty, hence why she wanted Christian's sperm b/c it'd make a beautiful child... Of course there's the issue of Christian being raped, so she's not my top choice, but I'd like to say it's her for most all other reasons. At the same time, the whole rape thing could have been done to throw everyone off. That'd be smart afterall. And she of course has access to anesthesia... MATT- So maybe, because let's face it- he's one screwed up kid that's kinda doing the angry at the world thing right now. Does that make him a psycho killer cutter dude? I dunno. But who really does know with this show? SEAN- has even more reason to do it: He found out his son wasn't his. His wife left him. He's shown violence, and he was cutting himself last week... and while he was a victim, you just never know. So while I'd like to think they wouldn't make it him, but at the same time it could happen. MINOR CHARACTERS: I don't think it'd be any of the minor characters we don't see around too much now because quite frankly that would make this story line be built up for NOTHING, and that would suck. I mean if it's some disposable person anyway, then who really cares? If you look on IMDB, Bobolit's character isn't scheduled guest again anytime soon, so unless they plan on dragging this out for another 2months, then I don't think it's gonna be him. |
I decided last night that it's Liz. She was so quick to turn on Christian, she has access to all the meds, and I think maybe she didn't give the fake victim enough anesthesia (sp?) b/c she was mad at her for faking it - so it was a way to get back at her. Though she doesn't seem quite crazy enough to kill someone....but it's always the "normal" ones! :p
|
Does anyone know if there is a particular date when the Carver's identity will be revealed?
|
Quote:
|
Last night's episode was awesome, in the 30 seconds that Christian was going into his office to see the latest Carver victim, I was trying to figure out who it was going to be, and I knew it was going to be someone good. Serves that chick right for trying to frame Christian.
But I still think the Carver is Quentin! KR - I WISH we knew when the Carver was going to be revealed...it better not drag into next season, or I'll be really mad! |
November sweeps are like 2weeks away- I'm pretty sure it'll come out then. That'd be the best time for it anyway.
|
Is it just me or was last night's episode really boring? The highlight was Gina giving blowjobs to every tile guy in Miami. Why didn't they even mention Detective McGraw or any developments with the Carver?
Next week's episode better be good! |
I thought last night's episode was boring, too. :( Last season seemed to keep my attention much more than this season.
I saw in interview with 'Christian' (don't know his real name) and he said the Carver would be revealed on the last episode of the season. |
Oh geez:rolleyes: I think that is just waayyyyy too long to drag the whole thing out.
|
As long as they really do reveal it in the season finale, I'll be happy. It is a long ways away, but I would be really mad if we had another Carver cliffhanger like last season.
Thanks for the inside info beanblossom! |
Quote:
|
Yo. How about Julia not murdering her mother?
AHAHAHAHA what a dumbass bitch. I just added the carver on my myspace. |
Don't even pretend like you know what's going on just because you watched one show Bobby...but thanks for reminding me to check out myspace.com/thecarver!
|
Quote:
i read somewheres that its going to be told the 20th i think, because thats the finale? maybe ? sorry crap i cant remember nowwww :rolleyes: but basically, im pretty sure its the finale episode they're going to tell us. |
If the Carver cuts beautiful people up to make them ugly (since he considers that natural) and he thinks plastic surgeons are monsters for doing what they do, how could it be Quentin?
It probably is because the writers will be dumb like that. I think it's Matt's friend that smoked pot and went to jail or maybe Bobble (my favorite character of all time). There also used to be this plastic surgeon that operated on transvestites and was an alcoholic; maybe it's him? -Rudey --The first season was way better though...much funnier. |
I don't think the carver could be any of the surgeons. I base that on the whole "beauty is a curse on the world" motto he keeps repeating - to continue working as a plastic surgeon all this time would violate that principle. He might be evil, but he does seem to have his own rules that he does follow.
Last week my theory was Gina. She has nothing to lose (HIV), hates Christian, plus all the nasty stuff she said to Kimber. Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned... This week I started thinking Julia. They keep saying that the Carver is a main character, and that his identity will be shocking. Julia has interactions with most of the victims, has motive for getting Kimber out of the way (christian), and definitely has some quirky little qualities. (I'm sorry, but that was creepycreepycreepy watching her smother the woman-she-thought-was-her-mom with the pillow) Julia's been looking for acceptance her whole life from her mother, and this week when she thought her mom was dead, Julia said she finally felt free. That's not a normal reaction to be that euphoric, even if you have trouble with a parent. Also, there's the whole giving up med school to be in sean's shadow all those years. There's definitely some resentment there, plus the infidelities and general craziness of their marriage. And don't forget how good she was with the scalpel when she was cutting the skin off of the Red Sox mother's body. For someone who allegedly hadn't done anything like that since med school years ago, she seemed a little TOO comfortable with the scalpel. My friend Beth's theory is that the Carver is actually Gina AND Julia, like the Scream movie. What do you guys think? |
I said that in my post Ralph! Stop biting my style!
If it's a main character, then I put my money on Matt. -Rudey --That little Michael Jackson wannabe is a killer if there ever was one. Quote:
|
Yes, I think its Matt too.
Tho last week the concept of Gina did occur to me. |
Quote:
-Rudey |
I haven't seen this show in awhile. Was Kimber murdered or something?
|
Quote:
|
What if the Carver is Jude (Julia's Med School buddy)? We haven't seen him in a while? And he was in Med School, let's not forget. Hmmm.......
|
Cutie Pie, you raise a good point! I was leaning towards Quentin all this time, but now he seems too obvious. Maybe Eva or Dr. Merrill Bobolit?
Has anyone else been checking out The Carver's Myspace ? Only two more episodes left in the season :( but hopefully we will learn who the Carver is! He better not kill Kimber, that's all I have to say. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
What was Famke Janssen's character on here? You know, the life-coach? I think it's her...
|
Quote:
;) Yeah, Famke Janssen is Ava, the life coach...it could possibly be her and Alec Baldwin as a team. I just really don't see it as being a major character, because then the show would be essentially over. ETA (after the show): NEXT WEEK IS GONNA BE CRAZY! I just really hope that they do reveal the Carver's true identity. |
T minus 13.5 hours!
Post your last minute Carver guesses!
I think it might be Eva. |
Matt
Matt's friend that raped the girl Bobble The old doctor that used to be Sean's mentor and became a drunk that operated only on transvestites. -Rudey |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:45 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.