What about a shield (like the Pi Alpha pin?)...maybe for Pref since ya'll will be wearing your badges...they can see how it's part of your badge...
We've done Apples for skit night (DG's and the City - you know, like the big apple)...
We also did life rings with an anchor beside them...
Little dresses would be cute too...especially if made out of cardstock with different colored fabric glued on top.
The sounds kinda hokie, but I've seen name tags in the shape of ties (like a mens tie you wear around your neck)...they are made much shorter and fatter though, and really do look kinda cute.
You should make a pair of glasses...either eye or sunglasses...
Okay, that's all I can think of off the top of my head...
__________________
There are friends who pass like ships in the night, who meet for a moment, then sail out of sight, with never a backward glance of regret...Friends we meet briefly then quickly forget.
Then there are friends who sail together, through quiet waters and stormy weather. Helping each other through joy and through strife. And those are the kind who give meaning to life.
~ ⚓ΔΓ⚓ ~