I don't think (or hope) the issue was with differring opinions, but with the fact that there were certain posters who CONTINOUSLY and PURPOSELY would turn any discussion into a WWE match - personal attacks, insults and all. Just out of the blue. That mess get very old after a short while.
I'm not talking about serious threads that dealt with racism or sexcism, but basic, simple threads about things like clothing or something like that. That alone was one of the reasons why I stopped frequenting Chit Chat.
On another note:
I like the new set-up, but then again, I like organization, so it flows with me.