American Idol 5 - Page 14

ZTAngel · #**196** 03-08-2006, 06:04 PM

Here's the thread in TWoP: http://forums.televisionwithoutpity....3135794&st=405

I think I started it on the page where they begin discussing her as a faker and there's a link to a website that talks about it.

SydneyK · #**197** 03-08-2006, 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by ZTAngel
Here's the thread in TWoP: http://forums.televisionwithoutpity....3135794&st=405
there's a link to a website that talks about it.

I read that... I'll buy the "laying it on thick" for votes idea, but who on Idol doesn't? Everybody has their agenda and their way of accomplishing it. Kellie is just going for the dumb girl approach.

I didn't read any of the "back story" (or whatever its called) so I don't know who her former friend is whose sharing this stuff. Whoever it is must have had a falling out with her for him/her to be saying such bad stuff. In which case, why should we trust him/her?

I'm not trying to say Kellie is the best by any means, but I think she's getting unnecessarily picked on. But maybe that's just what she gets for playing the dumb role.

kansas13 · #**198** 03-08-2006, 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by ZTAngel
Here's the thread in TWoP: http://forums.televisionwithoutpity....3135794&st=405

I think I started it on the page where they begin discussing her as a faker and there's a link to a website that talks about it.

Interesting forum and interesting site that they linked us too. Of course you can't always believe people that write into a website to smack talk about a friend, but there were some other valued sources in that site.

I wish America would pick an Idol on talent then on looks!! Who knows, maybe this year that may happen. Her voice, in my opinion, is not Idol material and I think the only thing that is keeping her there is her looks and personality

kddani · #**199** 03-08-2006, 11:09 PM

how was tonight??? i missed it, I was out to dinner

texas*princess · #**200** 03-09-2006, 12:31 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by ZTAngel
There's reports all over the TWoP AI message boards that Kellie isn't who she says she is. She claims that she has never sang in front of an audience before but they found pictures and articles about her competing in the Miss North Carolina pagaent. Her talent was singing. She was also in a North Carolina singing competition.
Also, the whole sheltered, poor girl schtick she uses is supposedly untrue as well.
I didn't like her to begin with so this only makes my opinions stronger.

wow...

i read through some of the boards and am just

.

One of their posters said something to the effect of:

She won't make it all the way. The judges are just singing her praises to get rid of the threats to their Chosen One, and then one week they will just rip her to shreds like they did to someone last season.

I have a feeling that's the truth or at least pretty close to it.

JenMarie · #**201** 03-09-2006, 01:51 AM

The judges soooooo want a guy to win this year.

Tongue baths all around.

The highlight: Taylor in a bunny suit.

His song was appropriate too. Finally, the Michael McDonald comparisons come to life.

Chris chose the wrong song... "Broken" only sounds good to me with Amy Lee singing vocals.

Elliot... blah... can't get the DJ Sammy song out of my head now.

Gedeon... forgettable.

Will... Didn't hear much of him... but eh.
Same with Kevin.

Ace... lots o' falsetto. Odd MJ song. It's was alright I guess.

Who am I forgetting?

_Opi_ · #**202** 03-09-2006, 03:03 AM

Ok..

So now I'm becoming a fan of Ace..I thought he did good tonite.

Taylor..How can you not like this guy?!

Elliot..he is still my fave even thou he sang that dreadful song. I liked how Randy said that he would sign him.

AznSAE · #**203** 03-09-2006, 11:29 AM

my dad likes this show and watches it every week.

CarolinaCutie · #**204** 03-09-2006, 12:14 PM

Every night on our 5:00 news, we have some sort of stupid American Idol segment where we talk about Chris, Kellie, Bucky (and Heather, before she got kicked off) since they are all from my viewing area. Sometimes we talk about Clay and especially Fantasia.

It is boring and is not news in any way, shape or form. I could live without ever seeing Bucky Central and his twin brother Rocky ever again. Yes, we get it. Chris used to work at Crown Honda here in Greensboro. Yep, thanks for sharing Kellie's grandfather's opinion for the 20th time.

HOW IS THIS NEWSWORTHY? Thank God I'm even WATCHING AI or else I would be really, really pissed that this drivel is on the news nightly.

In other news, I loved Ace's version of the Michael song, but I also loved when he did "Father Figure". I like it when he is creepy, I guess.

I am going to cry if/when Kevin goes home. He isn't the best in the competition by far but we love that owlish-faced tiny-mouthed little guy.

Chris is hot, Will is cheesy, Gideon has a lovely voice but looks like a freaking MUPPET (stop smiling!), Taylor needs to never dance again, I HATE BUCKY, and I actually had to go to the American Idol website to figure out who I am forgetting which shows you just how much I care about Elliott. Please remove your gross teeth from my TV screen, even though you are a talented singer.

KDAngel · #**205** 03-09-2006, 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by CarolinaCutie
Chris is hot, Will is cheesy, Gideon has a lovely voice but looks like a freaking MUPPET (stop smiling!), Taylor needs to never dance again, I HATE BUCKY, and I actually had to go to the American Idol website to figure out who I am forgetting which shows you just how much I care about Elliott. Please remove your gross teeth from my TV screen, even though you are a talented singer.

I hate Bucky too! Seriously! And I'm from NC and I just can't stand seeing him. Maybe if I closed my eyes and watched him it's be okay, but what kind of Idol is that?

Elliot is still amazing. And I LOVE LOVE LOVE Taylor. Like he can't dance, but he still makes me smile!

NutBrnHair · #**206** 03-09-2006, 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by KDAngel
I hate Bucky too! Seriously! And I'm from NC and I just can't stand seeing him. Maybe if I closed my eyes and watched him it's be okay, but what kind of Idol is that?

And, AND, AND...He's a twin! There are TWO of them! Bucky and Rocky. Geesh.

AnonAlumna · #**207** 03-09-2006, 01:44 PM

I think Bucky sounded amazing last night (although, I only caught the playback cuz I had to ANTM!) I just can't stand to look at him! I'm so glad that Elliott shaved!

texas*princess · #**208** 03-09-2006, 10:06 PM

I'm sad to see Ayla go

THe song she picked was a poor choice, but she really is a great singer!!!!

oh well...

I'll be rooting for Katherine now from the girls, and Chris from the guys..

texas*princess · #**209** 03-09-2006, 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by CarolinaCutie
Every night on our 5:00 news, we have some sort of stupid American Idol segment where we talk about Chris, Kellie, Bucky (and Heather, before she got kicked off) since they are all from my viewing area. Sometimes we talk about Clay and especially Fantasia.

It is boring and is not news in any way, shape or form. I could live without ever seeing Bucky Central and his twin brother Rocky ever again. Yes, we get it. Chris used to work at Crown Honda here in Greensboro. Yep, thanks for sharing Kellie's grandfather's opinion for the 20th time.

HOW IS THIS NEWSWORTHY? Thank God I'm even WATCHING AI or else I would be really, really pissed that this drivel is on the news nightly.

Are you watching the news on FOX?

Every single newscast over here they have a segment on AI

CarolinaCutie · #**210** 03-10-2006, 03:09 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by texas*princess
Are you watching the news on FOX?

Every single newscast over here they have a segment on AI

Nope, it's the NBC news channel, although it's the local broadcast.

Tonight: Kellie Pickler's FIRST JOB! I guess I forgot to tune in.

I'm sure everyone in the entire world disagrees, but I am really excited that Kevin didn't get voted off tonight- I really love his little owl-y face. WHY DID GIDEON GO INSTEAD OF BUCKY?