American Idol Season 4 - Page 10

2Tuff2Quit · #**136** 03-01-2005, 01:48 AM

I really really really like David, I think he is the best guy singer. Behind him is the large white guy (can't remember his name). I thought that those where the two that sounded natural, and like they weren't straining or trying too hard.
Me and my roomate where sitting in the living room watchin the two rock and roll guys like

. She was like..American Idol must be trying to go in a new direction. I don't particularly like them, but the judges seem too like them a lot.

1savvydiva · #**137** 03-01-2005, 02:06 AM

Nikko was my favorite tonight.

MeezDiscreet · #**138** 03-01-2005, 10:17 AM

i like scott, bo and david. nikko isn't too far behind (is it just me or did he even look better last night? maybe because he was dressed well).

the guy who sang lionel richie tripped me out!! you can't tell him he aint sexy. and all those usher-like activities have got to stop until he gets a record deal--and last night he sounded like poop so...

RBL · #**139** 03-01-2005, 10:23 PM

Say what you will about Mikalah Gordon she just NAILED "God Bless the Child"... it was brilliant

DSTinguished1 · #**140** 03-01-2005, 10:25 PM

Yesss she has my vote! You don't see too many white people choosing to do a song like that and sounding so soooulful!

RBL · #**141** 03-01-2005, 11:04 PM

Overall... the girls were NOT good tonight... exception Mikalah

2Tuff2Quit · #**142** 03-02-2005, 01:23 AM

The only girl that I wanted to see was Aloha and she didn't do to well, so that put a damper on my viewing experience. I didn't think that anyone did really well tonight. I think the guys had a much better night yesterday. I don't see any "Idol" potential right now. After Fantasia it is going to be really hard to follow in her shadow. I think she was a rare find and they probably aren't going to find another person like that. Don't get me wrong Aloha and Vonzell can sing but Fantasia had everything. The sound the stage presence the star potential, and I just don't see that in any of these girls.

Neosoulchild · #**143** 03-02-2005, 01:46 AM

Man, I had to take American Idol off of my DVR last week so I could record Project Runway and Kevin Hill, and I forgot to put it back on for this week. I wanted to hear David. So I take it he did well? I just watched the girls, and I didn't think they were that bad. I still liked Vonzell's performance. I hope I get to see the recaps of David's performance tomorrow.

skywalker20_99 · #**144** 03-02-2005, 02:51 PM

Scott and Bo Brice are among my favorites. Although Bo is a rocker, he has a great voice and could probably sing a variety of styles. I know she can be a bit annoying, but I really like Mikayla too. I was ticked at Randy for giving Janae such a hard time last night. I actually thought she was one of the better performers last night.

Which one is David?

2Tuff2Quit · #**145** 03-02-2005, 02:58 PM

David is the dark skinned guy with the shoulder length dreads.

Neosoulchild · #**146** 03-03-2005, 01:24 AM

Was David really that bad? I can't believe he's already off the show. He was my favorite.

1_zetaemerald · #**147** 03-03-2005, 02:35 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Neosoulchild
Was David really that bad? I can't believe he's already off the show. He was my favorite.

IMO, I don't think he was that bad, they were just hating!!! He was my favorite too! Travis should have never made the show!!! David was better than Travis anyday!!! but I feel you neosoulchild, David was my favorite too. I miss him already!

*crying* I miss David!! WWWHHHHHYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!

Missam05 · #**148** 03-03-2005, 09:43 PM

Man I was thinking the same thing..he didn't do as bad as Travis did oh my gosh that song was horrible..

I haven't read the posts about Aloha but I personally liked her and didn't think her and Vonzel should have been at the bottom this week...just got to up my votes next week..

RBL · #**149** 03-03-2005, 09:53 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by 1_zetaemerald
IMO, I don't think he was that bad, they were just hating!!! He was my favorite too! Travis should have never made the show!!! David was better than Travis anyday!!! but I feel you neosoulchild, David was my favorite too. I miss him already!

*crying* I miss David!! WWWHHHHHYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!

I liked him too but he was such a dissapointment as far as the competition goes

....What was making me mad was the judges telling Aloha/Vonzelle they can't do A. Keys cuz she is on top of her game...I'm like WTF....Stevie Wonder was on top of his game but they will compliment the contestants when they do his SONGS...so what i got from that was you can do Stevie but not Alicia???? I like A. Keys and all but she is NO Stevie

abaici · #**150** 03-04-2005, 05:22 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by RBL
What was making me mad was the judges telling Aloha/Vonzelle they can't do A. Keys cuz she is on top of her game...I'm like WTF....Stevie Wonder was on top of his game but they will compliment the contestants when they do his SONGS...so what i got from that was you can do Stevie but not Alicia???? I like A. Keys and all but she is NO Stevie

I was SOOOO mad about that. Again, I think A. Keys is cool, but come on

. As for Janaye singing a Blu Cantrell song, I didn't know that was an option.

I'm officially sone with this show. Aloha was my girl. For now, it's off the Season Pass. Maybe later.