This may be a little too punk for what you're going for, but '87 by the Bouncing Souls is another good one.
Good call!!
With a Little Help from my Friends by Joe Cocker (a'la Wonder Years!)
Closer to Fine by the Indigo Girls (this is actually one of our official chapter songs)
Higher and Higher- Jackie Wilson
Swing Life Away- Rise Against (again, may be a bit too heavy for ye, but if done right...)
Hybrid Mode
