Survivor: All Stars

[mu_agd]

Originally posted by OohTeenyWahine
I like Boston Rob, but he needs to go. Seriously, I won't be surprised if he'll start to turn on Amber soon.

i'm not so sure about that, considering they are still dating. i'd think if he turned on her, that would be the end of the relationship.

[stagebear]

i hope that the tribe kicks rob off next. it's obvious that he's pulling all of the strings and that he's good enough to keep winning all of the immunities. if they dont get rid of him soon, i guess it's their own fault that they get voted off.
on the other side, it's smart to take him to the final two since the first two jurors dont like him. and the rest of the jury probably wont vote for him either since he'll most likely screw them all over.

[polarpi]

Originally posted by stagebear
on the other side, it's smart to take him to the final two since the first two jurors dont like him. and the rest of the jury probably wont vote for him either since he'll most likely screw them all over.

Not necessarily.

Remember with the last season (Pearl Islands) during the reunion show, Jeff asked the jury if Lil had taken Jonny Fairplay to the final two if that would've changed their vote. I think it was closer than what it was with Sandra v Lil, but Lil would've won. It all depends on the jury members and their mentality....do you vote for the person who played the game the best (which at this point may actually be Boston Rob) or for the person who you like the best out of the two.

[AXO_MOM_3]

What happened this week? We missed it due to a school play. I heard Alicia was voted off.

[polarpi]

Okay, let me see if I can remember....

The reward challenge wound up being the ceramic masks, where the survivors had to first answer questions about who they felt was not worthy of being an All-Star, etc and then had to answer the questions how they thought everyone ELSE answered them. Alicia was surprised to hear she was one of the two picked as not worthy of being an All-Star (along with Shii-Ann) and then for thinking herself smarter than she really is. Rupert wound up winning, and it was a group reward where Rupert assigned the type of meal each person got. He basically let people choose what they wanted in a specific order: he took the steak with open bar privilieges, Rob took the burger and fries and cola, Jenna took the hot dog, Amber took the ham sandwich, Alicia took the salad, Tom got the potatoes, and Shii Ann wound up with the rice and water from their camp.

The immunity challenge was their one arm was chained to a bucket above their heads filled with water, and they had to stand there the longest (like we couldn't figure that one out ) Shii Ann wound up winning immunity and was very vocal and cutting in her celebration (which you can't blame her since she knew she would go otherwise).

Alicia was voted out and she wasn't expecting it, so she became the third member of the jury.

Does anyone else remember other details?

[AXO_MOM_3]

Thanks Polarpi - I knew I could count on you!

[polarpi]

Originally posted by AXO_MOM_3
Thanks Polarpi - I knew I could count on you!

Aww, thanks

Normally I'd probably remember more about the episode, but these next few weeks are going to be MAJORLY stressful!

[ajuhdg]

Nice recap!

I was so happy for Shii Ann winning the immunity. She isn't necessarily my favorite, but I was happy for her! The show was going to be really boring otherwise! It would basically be 'the Godfather' choosing each week! Why does it always happen like this? EVERY Survivor, the contestants are so blind! I would've jumped with Kathy and gotten Rob or Amber out of there!

aj

[AGDee]

Originally posted by ajuhdg
Nice recap!

I was so happy for Shii Ann winning the immunity. She isn't necessarily my favorite, but I was happy for her! The show was going to be really boring otherwise! It would basically be 'the Godfather' choosing each week! Why does it always happen like this? EVERY Survivor, the contestants are so blind! I would've jumped with Kathy and gotten Rob or Amber out of there!

aj

I agree. Rob is so strong there is a good chance he'll win more immunity challenges and if the others have any chance of winning, they should realize that they need to get rid of him. The only thing I can figure is that each of them are hoping to be in the final 3 with Rob and Amber, win immunity and then go against Rob in the Final 2. Then they would hope that Rob had made so many people so angry with betrayed alliances that they would vote for the other person as the winner. Of course, I'm torn between rooting for "anybody but Rob" and wanting Amber to win (because she's a sister and I think she has played it pretty smart herself so far).

Dee

[vanda]

Did you see the smiles on Lex & Cathy's faces when Alicia got the boot? Priceless! What made it sweeter for Shii Ann was the fact Alicia was telling her remember the game isn't over and she had to go home with them when Shii Ann was celebrating. She has to work her butt off to stay in the tribe, but I think she may be a goner. When is the tribe gonna wake up and Get rid of Boston Rob? He is the ultimate jerk.

[Lady Pi Phi]

Originally posted by vanda
Did you see the smiles on Lex & Cathy's faces when Alicia got the boot? Priceless! What made it sweeter for Shii Ann was the fact Alicia was telling her remember the game isn't over and she had to go home with them when Shii Ann was celebrating. She has to work her butt off to stay in the tribe, but I think she may be a goner. When is the tribe gonna wake up and Get rid of Boston Rob? He is the ultimate jerk.

I think that's why Alicia got the boot. If she had kept her mouth shut it just might have been Rupert that got the boot.

[ajuhdg]

This isn't exactly about the show, but I am so excited! I just received a box from my husband, and it had a bunch of 'authentic Survivor All-Stars buffs'. The CBS people have been really supportive of the soldiers in Iraq, and sent them all kinds of stuff (DVD's, buffs, etc). They are really cool, and not at all what I expected! For those girls that where them as tops, they have got to be stick thin, because they aren't that wide!

aj

[AOIIalum]

Well, the final is tonight and because it's Mother's Day I know I'll get my TV of choice and unlimited popcorn I hope we get to hear a lot out of the jury at some point.

So, who's gonna win? Any guesses?

[tinydancer]

I hope I'm wrong, but I'm afraid Rob is going to win. I can't stand listening to him talk all the time.

[The1calledTKE]

I hope Jenna wins.