American Idol 5

[BetteDavisEyes]

Originally posted by ZTAngel
And Paula needs to go back to the way she was acting at the beginning of the season: lucid.

THANK YOU!


I've been saying this for ages now b/c the woman is seriously drunk or on drugs b/c I can't decipher half the comments she makes.

[KDAngel]

Wow Kellie- you suck. Seriously. Go home NOW!!

Elliot was the all-star of the night. Hands down.

Despite Mandisa's early exit, the season has done suprisingly well with keeping the best around. Don't get me wrong- Bucky, Ace, Kellie don't add up to the others, but someone has to stick around with them.

I'm at a loss for who I want to win. I LOVE Taylor, but he's not the next American Idol to me.

It's either Elliot or Katharine for me.

Chris is too rock for me and Paris is just too... Paris, even though she was an early fave of mine. I wouldn't mind seeing Chris win either, he's just not my top pick.

[angelic1]

correct me if i'm wrong..

but don't they always say bad things about most people at this point in the competition if they try to do someone like whitney houston...

its just not a good song choice based on how the judges usually react..

but i still liked it..

[Xylochick216]

I enjoyed Elliot, Katharine, and Taylor. Chris was OK, Paris was decent, and Kellie was AWFUL.

Dialidol.com has been right over 80% of the time. If they're right tonight, Kellie's around for one more week. Ugh.

[LeslieAGD]

Were the judges listening last night?!? I loved Katherine's performance. Elliot and Chris were great, too.

[KatieKate1244]

Taylor is really growing on me, I really enjoyed his performance last night. I thought Katherine was good as well, and don't know why the judges were so hard on her.

As far as Kellie sticking around, MSNBC ran an article yesterday about how "white trash" is trendy right now. I wonder if that has anything to do with her appeal.

[JenMarie]

"Hey Andrea, what color is Kellie's hair?"

"Blond."

BWAHAHAHA!

I don't know why, but I found that to be really funny.

There are only certain kinds of people that should sing Unchained Melody. Kellie, my friends, is not one of them. I don't care how Leanne Rhimes you get, but it just doesn't mix. It was just DULL. I felt nothing for that song... just wanted it to end. And I LIKE that song. And the whole "pottery buddy" bit was just scary.

I like Chris, Elliot and parts of Katherine's performance. I think David Foster finally taught her to sing in the right key that is best for her. But the performance itself seemed weird. I dunno.

I would like Kellie to leave... this is about where Carmen left in Season two... so I'm hoping she'll do the same. Otherwise... maybe Paris or something.

[BetteDavisEyes]

Kellie sucks beyond belief & needs to go.


Paula needs to sober up prior to filming.

[ADPiShannan]

Its def Kellies turn to go. She was very bad.

My bottom 3 are: Kellie, Paris, and I really down know who else

The person I am like more and more is Katharine. I thought she was good though they tore her apart.

I thought Elliott was good but not worthy of Paula crying.

[bucutie02]

watching american idol again this afternoon I realized how good I thought Chris' performance really was. Man- i fell in love with him today listening to that song- what a hottie!

my bottom three: Kellie, Paris and Taylor?? whatever, I just know that Kellie NEEDS to go home!

[ZTAngel]

Kellie is the Carmen Rasmusen of this season.

.....except 10 times trashier

[SSS1365]

Actually, I think the judges were right about Katherine... she did kind of oversing it. But she wasn't horrible or anything.

I agree with everyone else- Kellie needs to GO!

[KatieKate1244]

YES!!!! Kellie is gone!!!!

[AOIIalum]

Hey, we agreed with America and Kellie is gone!

i'm sad but i understand kellie had to go