American Idol 4 - Page 14

ZTAngel · #1 03-07-2005, 10:59 PM

I want whatever happy pills Paula is on because she seems to think everyone is good. Including those who are really, really bad.

Scott- Really good. He actually moved around.
Bo- Shaky. It wasn't his best performance and it certainly wasn't as good as last week.
Anthony- He was really pitchy. I hope he goes this week but I doubt it since he's got that teen fan base.
Nikko- Really bad on the low notes but amazing at the powerful, high notes.
Travis- Great performer but sucky vocals. Really sucky vocals.
Mario- He sang it well but I wasn't blown away by it.
Constantine- He thinks he's Eddie Vedder by the way he plays with the microphone stand and does that looking-down-while-playing-with-his-hair-trying-to-be-sexy thing. Except, the difference is that Eddie looks good while doing it and he can sing. Constantine sucks. Please go home!
Anwar- He did great! Best performance of the night.

Oh, I heard Fantasia's 'Baby Mama' song on the radio today. Gag.

RBL · #2 03-07-2005, 11:00 PM

LOVED NIKKO.. BEST OF THE NIGHT

texas*princess · #3 03-07-2005, 11:02 PM

I love Nikkos voice!

Anwar was AWESOME!

I REALLY don't like Constantine!!! He needs to not be on this show anymore!

ZTAngel - I heard that Baby Mama song the other day... my first thought was: "oooooooooook?"

tinydancer · #4 03-07-2005, 11:27 PM

Anwar - oh my goodness!!!

I think Travis and Constantine leave us this time.

roqueemae · #5 03-07-2005, 11:30 PM

I heard Baby Mama on Regis and Kelly. I had to stop getting ready for work to listen. I couldn't believe it was real. I was hoping it was just a novelty for the Baby Week but evidently not.

BetteDavisEyes · #6 03-08-2005, 03:00 AM

Bo & Anwar just blew me away. I tried voting & am still trying but the lines are busy, busy, busy. That's a good thing though!

chideltjen · #7 03-08-2005, 03:08 AM

I TiFauxed this epi and watched it back. (My bf can record TV on his computer.)

I think Travis is definitely a shoe in for the reject pile. Yes the guy can dance and that's great and all... but I wasn't feeling Bobby Brown. And he was flat.

And ConstantCrap ruined my favorite Police song. I hope he goes... really. He wasn't in tune the entire time.

I did like: Anwar and Nikko. Nikko is cute and Anwar sings. Awesome combo for the top 12. I just hope Nikko doesn't just make it to the top 12 only to meet Charles G's fate a la Season 2. But I want his glasses! And Anwar is just.fabulous.

I liked Bo. Good for top 12 too. The song is overdone but whatever's clever. I still think he should just drop the competition and move to Seattle, but that's just me.

Clay 2.5: sings Marc Anthony... which was... odd. Not as odd as Clay singing "Grease," as Simon wished to throw out. Something just didn't work for me. But he's safe I'm sure. I'm still trying to figure out what was on his jacket though. I want to say he rubbed up against a chalkboard or something.

Scott... I'm on the fence about him. Not sure if I dig him or not. Though the jazz hands cracked me up.

And I kinda forgot about Mario's performance. But I did remember he wasn't wearing a hat and NO he's not balding.

Tomorrow... the ladies! Boyfriend was depressed that I had to make him watch the men tonight. haha.

AXO Alum · #8 03-08-2005, 11:31 AM

Great recaps!! Thanks for keeping me up-to-date -- I had to do fabulous grocery shopping last night so I missed it.

I am sad to hear that Travis didn't do so well - I'll still wait for his album

PLEASE let Anthony & Constannoying go home tonight -- I really don't want to live with the two of them on TV for the next 50 weeks!!

ZTAngel · #9 03-08-2005, 11:34 AM

I hope that Constantine, Anthony or Travis goes home this week but, unfortunately, life isn't fair so I have a feeling that it will be Travis and Scott.

shadokat · #10 03-08-2005, 12:23 PM

I know I'll get hammered for this, but I think that American Idol is about more than just being able to sing, although being able to sing is obviously important. I look at someone like Scott, who if I'm being honest, does not have the "look" of a pop star, and his vocals are ok, he deserves the boot. Now Travis, he can dance and he's charismatic, and the vocals were BAD, but for some reason, I still liked what he did. Maybe it's just an eye candy thing

Anyways, nobody blew me away tonight...Anwar was good, as was Nikko. I think it'll be Travis and Anthony tonight, although I hope Anthony stays, as he's my home town boy.

Let's start a GET RID OF CONSTANTINE campaign. He ruined the Police song forever!

SSS1365 · #11 03-08-2005, 03:29 PM

I like Travis because he's the local boy... and he's a hottie, which doesn't hurt!

But his performance last night was very disappointing. Who does Bobby Brown for AI???

I'd like to see Constantine, Scott, or Anthony go home. Anthony's got too many teenage girl fans, so I'm gonna hope for Constantine and Scott to go home. Unfortunately, Constantine also has the teenage girl fans, so who knows?

amycat412 · #12 03-08-2005, 03:46 PM

What did Bo sing?

FeeFee · #13 03-08-2005, 05:20 PM

I had 8:00 class last night, so I missed AI.

I *heart* Anwar's voice.

cash78mere · #14 03-08-2005, 05:40 PM

travis and constantine need to go home! what is up with constantine's chin? it creeps me out! and brush your hair boy!

i loved bo, anwar and mario. they were great.

scott, anthony and nikko were okay. i didn't love them but didn't hate them.

can't wait for tonight!

SATX*APhi · #15 03-08-2005, 10:40 PM

I was too busy working on a presentation and paper and just realized AI was on. I also missed last night's episode.