Unwritten rules (until now)...let's talk about 'em

[Kevin]

Originally Posted by MysticCat

Can someone please repeal the unwritten rule that it is necessary for the audience to stand during the Hallelujah Chorus?

I've played this piece a number of times and have never heard of the audience standing. I'm not a singer though, so maybe it's a different experience?

[MysticCat]

Originally Posted by Kevin

I've played this piece a number of times and have never heard of the audience standing. I'm not a singer though, so maybe it's a different experience?

The story, first recorded 30+ years after Messiah's premiere, is that King George stood as the chorus started and remained standing throughout. Depending on who you ask or what source you consult, the reason supposedly was (1) to acknowledge the "King of Kings and Lord of Lords," (2) because he was so moved by the music, or (3) to stretch his legs. But when the king stands, everone else present must stand.

But whatever the reason, it's been going on since the 1750s or so, on both sides of The Pond.

[amanda6035]

Originally Posted by MysticCat

The story, first recorded 30+ years after Messiah's premiere, is that King George stood as the chorus started and remained standing throughout. Depending on who you ask or what source you consult, the reason supposedly was (1) to acknowledge the "King of Kings and Lord of Lords," (2) because he was so moved by the music, or (3) to stretch his legs. But when the king stands, everone else present must stand.

But whatever the reason, it's been going on since the 1750s or so, on both sides of The Pond.

Funny. We sang this during the our church cantata this year, and Bill, the guy who sits next to me (I sing tenor) made a comment about whether or not everyone would stand "as they are supposed to" and sure enough, everyone did.

I dunno. I kinda like it.... for reason #1.