2012 College Football Thread

[wareagle93]

Originally Posted by AXOmom

I'd heard about where we were ranked - hadn't seen them yet (Thank you Knight Shadow for the post)....I'm good with it. If I was going to be really persnickity I'd fuss about coming in behind Oklahoma, but we will have a new QB and no LaMike, so I can see how that could go either way.

Overall, I don't see anything that makes me go AACK! Are these pollsters all on meth!

I don't get putting Notre Dame (again) in the top 25 since they haven't done much in the last what...15 years to justify that ranking in my opinion, but it seems inevitable. I think Georgia is ranked too high, but I'd put them in the top 25 still. FSU....mmm, I think it's too high...not sure where I would put them. I think Nebraska and Oklahoma State have a complaint and are too low. Now if the BCS would just call me to get it all straight, there'd be no problems and we'd have a completely fair system....at least fair from my perspective. LOL.

EA: I think LSU is still top 5, but these rankings came out, I believe, before the whole Honey Badger fiasco, so that might change things slightly for them.

Wow, we think alike on pretty much everything!

-LaMichael James was a great player, but Oregon should be fine with Kenjon Barner and DeAnthony Thomas. Barner would have started for a majority of teams in the country the last few years, but it just so happened that Oregon had one of the most explosive players in the country just ahead of him on the depth chart. Darron Thomas was a good QB, but Brian Bennett is really good.

-I agree with you on Notre Dame. This year, their schedule really amps up. Adding in Miami, Oklahoma (on the road) and I believe they also have BYU. Outside of Charlie Weis' 1st 2 years, they haven't really been relevant on a consistent basis since the end of the Lou Holtz era.

-Georgia has some really good skill players on offense (even with the loss of Crowell, and they have 2 stud freshman running backs coming in), and their defense (when everyone comes back) could possibly be the best in the country. A trio of Jenkins, Rambo, and Jones is just scary. All 3 are potential 1st round picks next April. Their Offensive Line, as it seems every year, is the biggest unknown. If that unit can gel, and given the fact that they don't play LSU, Arkansas or Alabama during the regular season, could result in them playing again for the SEC Championship, and perhaps even the National Championship.

-FSU is definitely on the right track. They should have a real good year. Jimbo has done a solid job recruiting, but I think they may be a year or two away (just wait for him to accumulate another 1 or 2 top 10 classes).

-Entering the 2010 season, Oklahoma State literally lost everyone, and most people picked them to finish last or second to last in their Big XII Division, and they won 11 games. They might not win 11 this year, but I can definitely see them winning about 9. Mike Gundy is one of the more underrated coaches in the country.

-I think that when the AP Poll comes out, either USC or Alabama will be ranked #1. Gun to my head, I'll say it will be USC.

[AXOmom]

Originally Posted by wareagle93

Wow, we think alike on pretty much everything!

-LaMichael James was a great player, but Oregon should be fine with Kenjon Barner and DeAnthony Thomas. Barner would have started for a majority of teams in the country the last few years, but it just so happened that Oregon had one of the most explosive players in the country just ahead of him on the depth chart. Darron Thomas was a good QB, but Brian Bennett is really good.

-I agree with you on Notre Dame. This year, their schedule really amps up. Adding in Miami, Oklahoma (on the road) and I believe they also have BYU. Outside of Charlie Weis' 1st 2 years, they haven't really been relevant on a consistent basis since the end of the Lou Holtz era.

-Georgia has some really good skill players on offense (even with the loss of Crowell, and they have 2 stud freshman running backs coming in), and their defense (when everyone comes back) could possibly be the best in the country. A trio of Jenkins, Rambo, and Jones is just scary. All 3 are potential 1st round picks next April. Their Offensive Line, as it seems every year, is the biggest unknown. If that unit can gel, and given the fact that they don't play LSU, Arkansas or Alabama during the regular season, could result in them playing again for the SEC Championship, and perhaps even the National Championship.

-FSU is definitely on the right track. They should have a real good year. Jimbo has done a solid job recruiting, but I think they may be a year or two away (just wait for him to accumulate another 1 or 2 top 10 classes).

-Entering the 2010 season, Oklahoma State literally lost everyone, and most people picked them to finish last or second to last in their Big XII Division, and they won 11 games. They might not win 11 this year, but I can definitely see them winning about 9. Mike Gundy is one of the more underrated coaches in the country.

-I think that when the AP Poll comes out, either USC or Alabama will be ranked #1. Gun to my head, I'll say it will be USC.

Well, if the 4 team play-off system doesn't work - we'll have to put our great minds together and come up with our own version of the BCS!.

I don't doubt Georgia's talent - I doubt their coach. Just not impressed with him so far. That softer schedule will definately help them, but I just can't see them playing for an NC this year. I could see them playing for an SEC championship and losing it. That, unfortunately won't help them finish in the top 4 since the SEC west is stronger.

I agree that FSU is improving, but do I think they've improved enough to put them in the top 10 - no. 11-15 I could see, but if there was one team I'm really just not sure where to put them - it's FSU.

I'm with you on Oklahoma State even though their QB is gone. Still like the coach, like the investment T. Boone's put into the program and think they are on the rise.

Conference loyatly should make me choose USC, but bleh....Objectively I'd agree with you though....however, they just had another defensive player, Devante Wilson, go down with a torn ACL and I think getting them through the season healthy will be a challenge. I think he's their third out for the season.

For us - I like Bryan Bennett, but he has quite a race on his hands. Marcus Mariotta lit up our spring game, so we don't know yet who our QB will be. We have two really good options and a soft schedule to start with that will give them time to acclimate, so that helps.

[TSteven]

Originally Posted by AXOmom

Well, if the 4 team play-off system doesn't work - we'll have to put our great minds together and come up with our own version of the BCS! .

[AXOmom]

Originally Posted by TSteven

Yes, that would in fact sum up what I mean by not working out. Of course if these ended up like last year's national championship (or as I like to call it, the Boredom Bowl), ESPN will take care of that in short order. They can't afford to lose that many viewers.