This was a good thread. I have tons more to add since I have not gone to the movies in ages but here are some
Finding Forrester (own it but too lazy to watch it, I will show it to my students
)
The Cider House Rules (have owned it for 2 years still in its wrapping)
I bought Cornbread Movie over Christmas for $5 along with some Speed and Jugs movie with Bill Cosby -- have not watched either.
Training Day
Monster's Ball
Threaded Mode