LOST - Season 5

[tangelo212]

Originally Posted by PhiMuTillIDie

So my little and I were discussing this week's episode today and we have a few theories:

The passengers on the plane are supposed to be representative of some of the original passengers, and even if some of the passengers are the same, they might not necessarily represent themselves (like Locke replacing Christian).

For example: Sayid was brought on by a woman who looks like a cop, won't leave his side and appears to be escorting him somewhere. The hunch is that he is replacing Kate. The cop with him is representing either Ana Lucia or the agent who was bringing Kate back to the U.S. (could be either, really).

The man who was in line behind Jack at the ticketing area said the same line Sayid said to Jack before the first flight (something about being sorry to hear about his loss), and previews for next week show him on the Island, so he's probably replacing Sayid.

We also suspect that Kate is pregnant (she DID just sleep with Jack), and therefore representing Claire, since she doesn't need to represent herself. Sun, Hurley and Jack are more likely than not themselves (Jack especially).

It's kind of a long-shot, but if you think about it, it makes sense.

I actually thought about this too. Don't forget, Hurley was carrying a guitar on the plane, so he could be representing Charlie.


I also really don't think Ben killed Penny, I just don't. He is capable of evil, but I don't think he killed her.

[BetteDavisEyes]

Originally Posted by tangelo212

I also really don't think Ben killed Penny, I just don't. He is capable of evil, but I don't think he killed her.

I disagree b/c last year, he ordered the crazy Russian guy to kill the 2 women guarding Charlie. He also orchestrated the death of everyone on the island associated with the Dharma Initiative and his own father. He even told Richard to leave his father's body in the car & not to retrieve it. Is it colder to order people to be killed or to kill someone yourself? Either way, I think Ben is capable of way more than you think.

[ASTalumna06]

Originally Posted by tangelo212

I also really don't think Ben killed Penny, I just don't. He is capable of evil, but I don't think he killed her.

Oh, I definitely think it's possible. Ben really only became 'friends' and helped everyone from the flight to save his own ass. I don't think his motives have ever been pure. I've been waiting for him to do something wrong/bad.

[twinkle555]

Ok so if the island can move physically and through time, then maybe that giant foot statue is what is left of the Colossus of Rhodes? And maybe the island at one point moved to the Antarctic...that would explain the polar bear from the first season? Who knows, just popped into my head...