American Idol 6

mu_agd · #1 04-19-2007, 06:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADqtPiMel

If Blake was ACTUALLY in the bottom three, I'll eat my hat.

Dial Idol was showing him as being in the bottom.. but then they haven't been all that accurate this season.

I wonder if Ryan Adams is pissed that they kept saying When the Stars Go Blue is a Tim McGraw song.

#2 04-19-2007, 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mu_agd

Dial Idol was showing him as being in the bottom.. but then they haven't been all that accurate this season.

I wonder if Ryan Adams is pissed that they kept saying When the Stars Go Blue is a Tim McGraw song.

Just ask Dolly Parton what she thinks of Whitney and "I Will Always Love You".

I have a chapter sister who didn't believe that it was actually a song pre-Tim McGraw.

I sent her the mp3s of Ryan Adams, Bono/Corrs, and OTH and even she agreed that those versions are way better.

dzfan · #3 04-19-2007, 04:26 PM

glad Sanjaya was kicked but sort of felt sorry for him when he started to cry last night -- did anyone else??

ΑΓΔSquirrel10 · #4 04-19-2007, 06:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dzfan

glad Sanjaya was kicked but sort of felt sorry for him when he started to cry last night -- did anyone else??

As I much as I disliked Sanjaya, I did begin to feel bad for him. The poor kid was BAWLING onstage! Of course I wanted to cry whenever the kid opened his mouth to sing, so I guess we're even

ZTAngel · #5 04-24-2007, 09:37 PM

Am I hearing something completely different than the judges? They loved Chris. I thought he was terrible.

texas*princess · #6 04-24-2007, 10:33 PM

I think LaKisha or Chris is next to peace out.

I wasn't impressed with Phil or Blake either.

irishpipes · #7 04-24-2007, 10:58 PM

I agree that Chris sounded pretty bad. Even Simon said he was good though??? I didn't think anyone was that great to be honest. I like Jordin, but when Randy said that was the best vocal ever on AI, I thought that was quite the stretch.

Predicted bottom two:
Chris
Lakisha (I love her but the judges have turned against her now and she has had back-to-back bad weeks)

xo_kathy · #8 04-24-2007, 11:58 PM

I didn't hear Chris, but I've been saying for a while I don't get why they fawn over him.

And I still love Lakisha. I can't believe they say she "shouts" but that the song tonight was so perfect by Fantasia. Fantasia is a horrible "screecher" and they never seemed to mind. Lakisha's tone is SO much better in my opinion.

Another eh week for me. I thought Jordin was good, but don't think it was one of the best perfromances ever on AI?!

JenMarie · #9 04-25-2007, 01:31 AM

I really liked Lakisha in the beginning of the season, but back to back Idol Alumnae songs for her songs? *sigh* I dunno.

MTSUGURL · #10 04-25-2007, 01:52 AM

I just gotta say, Melinda brings people to Jesus.
I can't stand Chris. He sounds like a boy band reject.
I still want to make out with Blake's voice.
Jordin is amazing, but I'm not going to say the best in AI history... I love that song though. Sang it in high school choir.
Phil. Um, ok. Not a fan.
LaKisha is slipping... I'm predicting that either she or Chris are gone next week.

AOIIalum · #11 04-25-2007, 07:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xo_kathy

And I still love Lakisha. I can't believe they say she "shouts" but that the song tonight was so perfect by Fantasia. Fantasia is a horrible "screecher" and they never seemed to mind. Lakisha's tone is SO much better in my opinion!

I thought she did well and I really like her, but she doesn't have a chance. Back-to-back Idol songs plus the judges's comments over the past few weeks will probably result in her elimination tonight.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MTSUGURL

I just gotta say, Melinda brings people to Jesus.

Amen! I adore her. I really don't think she'll win, but here's hoping that she goes out like Chris Daughtry and has nice post-Idol career.

Blake annoys me. Must be my age.

Chris wasn't as good as the judges said last night. Difference in live and in person vs. "live" on tv? Subtle judging manipulation? He sounded terrible, especially in comparison to the rest of the 6.

I do like Phil but he's not the next American Idol.

Jordin was amazing last night. That was her "Stuff Like That There" and it wouldn't surprise me if she won the whole thing. Best performance ever on Idol? Nope, but in the top five.

ΑΓΔSquirrel10 · #12 04-25-2007, 09:57 PM

Whoa...

I don't have any words for this episode

kddani · #13 05-01-2007, 08:56 PM

Okay, so the drummer needs to lay off the cowbell. I've noticed it being really strong in several songs. Particularly in Melinda's.

The only person I've been even mildly entertained by is Blake. The rest was like bad karaoke. Bon Jovi is pretty standard fair for karaoke.

I hate when they narrow it to one band that they can pick songs from it really screws a lot of people. Bon Jovi has a good amount of songs, but they all want to pick songs that the crowd knows. But one band's songs are not one-size-fits-all