American Idol ....yea Or Nay?

Originally posted by Impressed SF
Red butchered one of the all time great songs. I never thought it was possible to sing a whole song flat but he did.

I really, really like Fantasia, George,Latoya, and Jasmine. I have a feeling that those talented people are going to be duking it out.

Who does everyone think is going to win the whole Shabang?

I've seen and heard drunk people sing "MY GIRL" on karaoke better than he did.

George, Latoya, and Jasmine did wonderful tonight, and it'll be no surprise if those three end up being the final three. "You're All I Need To Get By" isn't the easiest of songs to sing, and it was GREAT to see Simon eat his words after George sang.