I love that dress! At 45% off, I'd grab it in both colors. My dd left for college with 2 LBDs that had a very similar silhouette, and these were incredibly handy for a variety of occasions.
Styled smartly, I think either of these would be an elegant statement for pref.
(Okay if someone does buy this dress, would you please provide feedback on size/fit -- especially petite size? Considering purchasing as a gift for daughter)