Thanks for all your help!!! The Recruitment Chairs and I met last night and we voted on our theme! (I found a piece of paper with themes on it from MGCA (Mid American Greek Conference)... and we used some of yours too.)
They chose...
No matter which way you go, you can't go wrong. (Street Signs)
(I found a piece of paper with themes on it from MGCA (Mid American Greek Conference)... and we used some of yours too.) 
Threaded Mode