|
I think it is unfair to compare WTE with the book and SATC with the TV series and then say the latter was better.
Movies seldom stay completely true to the book, plus readers have also formed their own images of characters, etc. This can lead to disappointment in the movie.
SATC the series already had created the images for the movie so everyone knew what to expect.
As someone who didn't watch the series (yeah I went today as a compromise with mini-me who went to see Indiana Jones with me last week) I thought SATC was a well-done, entertaining movie and saw nothing wrong with the JHud role. However, I personally still relate better to WTE.
__________________
DSQ
Born: Epsilon Xi / Zeta Chi, SIUC
Raised: Minneapolis/St. Paul Alumnae
Reaffirmed: Glen Ellyn Area Alumnae
All in the MIGHTY MIDWEST REGION!
|
Threaded Mode
