I'm on my third pair of Uggs, and I'm addicted. I can usually get two snow belt winters out of a pair before I have to toss them (and this is wearing them pretty much every day from October to March). DEFINITLY waterproof whichever ones you get. I've had the traditional camel, the chocolate, and right now I have the chestnut. The chocolate ones weren't my favorite because they showed salt stains really bad. I vote grey personally- I've been eying them myself!
Threaded Mode