Honest to God, I've gotten the most compliments on Skin Musk. It's a cheapy perfume you can get at the drug store. I read an interview with Sarah Jessica Parker once and she said she wore it, too. I haven't worn it in a while though b/c it's a little heavy for summer.
I get my second most complements on Chanel Coco Mademoiselle.
I also wear Marc Jacobs - very light and nice for everyday.
Threaded Mode