Immigration bill protests: "A Day Without Latinos"

[TristanDSP]

Just thought I'd get everyone's opinions on the protests over the immigration bill they're talking about. Last week, a bunch of students down here missed school to go march over the bill.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/kgtv/20060407/lo_kgtv/3382875

Another immigration reform event is brewing -- inspired by the 2004 movie "A Day Without A Mexican," 10News reported.

Activists said Monday, May 1 will be called, "A Day Without Latinos" -- a boycott of work, school and shopping for those who participate nationwide.

[AOII_LB93]

Cardinal Mahoney is saying not to do it to the people of LA because boycotting isn't going to get anyone anywhere on this issue and it causes anger and mistrust. (his words not mine, there was an article about it on MSN earlier last week.)

I guess my question is, what about the rest of the people who come to this country illegally? This bill doesn't affect them? Why not try to get all the immigrants in on this and not just latinos? Granted immigrants of hispanic descent are the largest number in the country, but there are lots of others as well. How many people have come over here legally via an airport, stayed "on vacation" and then just never left?

The school where I teach was affected by the walkouts, though not much, only about 60 students did it and our school is about 35% hispanic with around 1900 students. Most of the students who walked out had little idea why they were doing it, and we just doing it because they wanted to miss class. Also the majority of the ones who walked aren't exactly upstanding students who tend to do well in their classes - quite honestly students who would have been better served to stay in school and attempt to learn about the issue in their history/social science classes as opposed to walking out and then marching to city hall with our principal in tow- he follwed because he knew if anyone got hurt, you know we'd be sued. What does city hall have to do with a federal bill?

Sticky issue...and one that will require some actual thought and true intelligent discussion if it is to be resolved in a reasonable manner.

[SOPi_Jawbreaker]

Well the protests are at least a better idea than what the College Republicans at Penn State wanted to do to promote the bill.

http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive...ps-edit-01.asp

These are the geniuses that two years ago had a party where members showed up in blackface, as a KKK member, as an "oversodomized frat pledge", and as a "sorostitute".

http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive...03dnews-08.asp

[Lady of Pearl]

Now if we could get both Latinos and African Americans to collaborate on the same day we could really affect the economy on that given day!

[PiKA2001]

Originally posted by Lady of Pearl
Now if we could get both Latinos and African Americans to collaborate on the same day we could really affect the economy on that given day!

What does this bill have to do with African Americans?

[macallan25]

Nahh, that would never happen, the blacks would be too lazy to do anything.

[starang21]

Originally posted by macallan25
the blacks would be too lazy to do anything.

interesting....

[macallan25]

Actually I could really care less....Just wanted to see how many "You are a racist, bigot, etc. etc. etc." responses I could get. Surprisingly GC was rather tame.

[starang21]

Originally posted by macallan25
Actually I could really care less....Just wanted to see how many "You are a racist, bigot, etc. etc. etc." responses I could get. Surprisingly GC was rather tame.

suuuuurrreee.

that and considering your post on "typical" black strippers.

[Rudey]

I think "Catch an illegal immigrant day" is funnier.

-Rudey

[squirrely girl]

Originally posted by AOII_LB93

I guess my question is, what about the rest of the people who come to this country illegally? How many people have come over here legally via an airport, stayed "on vacation" and then just never left?

statistically speaking there are more of those particular illegal immigrants (and the ones who came to college here and never left) than those who "border jump" from mexico - despite what the xenophobes would have you believe.

- marissa

[PiKA2001]

Originally posted by squirrely girl
statistically speaking there are more of those particular illegal immigrants (and the ones who came to college here and never left) than those who "border jump" from mexico - despite what the xenophobes would have you believe.

- marissa

Let's see those statistics then, because I find that really hard to believe.

[AchtungBaby80]

Originally posted by PiKA2001
Let's see those statistics then, because I find that really hard to believe.

I was wondering about that, too. I'm not saying that statement is wrong, because I don't know, but I find it very surprising as well.

[Kevin]

Originally posted by squirrely girl
statistically speaking there are more of those particular illegal immigrants (and the ones who came to college here and never left) than those who "border jump" from mexico - despite what the xenophobes would have you believe.

- marissa

You have no way of proving this, and I highly doubt it's true. There will be records of those who overstay visas while there are no records for whatever "border jumpers" as you call them come into the country illegally.

[AGDee]

Granted, it's a small sample size I'm talking about here, but I lived in the International dorm on my campus for two years back in the mid 80's and the vast majority of the foreign students on my floor had no intention of ever going back to their home countries, especially the Iranian students (this was during the Iran-Iraq war and as soon as they stepped foot in Iran again, they were going to have to go fight in the military). It was right after the Shah was booted and things had gone from a Western type civilization to an extremist regime. The women were particularly determined not to return because they had no rights there. I know for sure that three of the Iranian students never left and ended up "legal" eventually, but it was years of hiding and running first. But, it wasn't just the Iranian students either. There were students from 18 countries on my dorm floor alone and I would be surprised if any of them returned home, because they really loved it here.

The funniest ones were the German guys who thought they could "road trip" to California (from Michigan) on a weekend, because they were used to other countries being nearby.. they didn't get just how big the US was! But, that's a hijack.