There are quite a few items, but it would depend on your budget. I've given quite a few of china boxes or small trays with violets on them (ebay item #330937741409 or
pin boxes or
trinket boxes, for the new initiate's pin. Lions are fun (from beanie babies to big ones), as are Christmas ornaments with any of the emblems on them. However, a shot glass or any other alcohol-related items are definitely frowned upon.
I'm sure that there are other ideas! Ladies?