I'm the former NMOC at Iota Theta. Depending on the size of your chapter, you can change these numbers.
Sisters who were on financial or academic probation were not eligible to receive a little sister. Of course, you cant tell the NMs who that is, so we would let them list their preference, top 3, or 5 pick. The Bigs would also do a preference, or, informally say "I really want Suzy NM" or "I dont feel a connection with Jackie, I'd rather not be her Big". Ultimately, it came down to the what the new member wanted. But, in our histoy and our small chapter, we have also had to purposely NOT put two girls together who we knew would be bad influences (funny, those girls arent members anymore...)
You just gotta take it on a case by case bases. We tried to give the NMs their first choice, if possible, and if it wasnt a "bad idea". If it wasn't possible to give them their first choice, then we went down the list hoping to give somebody she would be happy with. We also took it out of our bylaws that you couldnt have more than 1 little. If a Big sister is well prepared and willing to take on the responsibility of having more than 1, and she wanted them like they wanted her, then she got them. We learned the hard way to not try to be "fair" to the bigs....ultimately, you should be "fair" to the NMs, that should be a priority. At least, it was in our case.
__________________
AΞΔ - Courage, Graciousness, & Peace
|