Today I was behind a woman (who got off the train with me at Grand Central and she was in work clothes so you know she'd from here!) who had not one, but TWO, scrunchies in her hair. A light blue and a navy - I almost asked her if she was a Kappa, but I knew she couldn't be!
I did want to say, "Did you NOT watch Sex and the City lady?!?"
I think Navy is good. Black is good too and easier to deal with the shoe color issue I think. Or grey is fine too, but a nice light shade. Good luck!
Wow, look at all these GC ladies coming to NYC! Of course, with Cream and I here I can't say I blame ya!!!