I think what was wrong with this show is that they used too much creative license in arranging these songs. Carrie's song: the tempo was really WEIRD. I don't remember that song much, but the band and Carrie just seemed really off. Clay Potter made a classic into a pop song and Nikko made a duet into an R&B ballad. I'm used to these songs the way they were in the originals. Whatever happened to picking a theme that the idols had to adhere to, not the theme had to adhere to the idols.
