Thread: American Idol 4
View Single Post
  #438  
Old 04-06-2005, 01:05 PM
chideltjen chideltjen is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Here, there, everywhere
Posts: 2,941
Send a message via AIM to chideltjen
Wow... someone please put Paula back in her cage.

I recorded AI and got to fast forward thru all the BS. Good times.

Scott: I didn't actually watch his performance. I just heard it. It didn't sound good. And like many others, I will agree that the DA scandal will shoot his fan base down and he'll go because of that. If he would have given a stellar performance, maybe he would have escaped. But it wasn't enough.

Constantine: I would have died if he would have done something from Rent... but they probably barred him from doing so, since he toured with a company and was Mark or something. I agree that when he isn't doing the rocker thing, he's not bad... but DUDE FREAKS ME OUT with those stalker eyes and isht. It's not cool.

Carrie: Of all the songs you could have picked that were bubble gum poppy, you picked the most boring out of the catalog. And I don't even remember that song being in King and I.

Clay Potter 2.0: I wondered if Anthony had really watched Sound of Music ever. "Climb Every Mountain" is sung by and meant for a elderly soprano woman... not a 19 year old male. I don't care HOW poppy you make it... it just doesn't work... EVER. I love that musical and Potter just committed sacrilege. BOOOOOO! It compares to a 2nd soprano trying to sing "Old Man River," which is meant for a baratone... bottom line: never sing songs that weren't meant for your voice.

Vonzell: I liked it. Go girl!

Nikko: I didn't think it sounded as horrible as Simon made it to sound. Though I was wondering how he was going to sing a song meant for a duet by himself. But the guy is R&B and only R&B. I'd hate to see him on a country night... if there is one.

Bo: Simon hun, it's BROADWAY night. Of course he's not going to sound like a rocker that he is. He picked a song at random because he'd never sang in musicals before... though, that excuse is poor because I'm sure there is some downtime to watch the movie rendition. It was okay. I thought he forgot the words in places.

Anwar: Better, much better. He's been redeemed. So hopefully he'll be safer this week.

Nadia: I don't remember this song at all. But she sounds pretty... just stop with all the crazy scary faces. I liked J-Hud's more than I like her's.

Bottom:
Clay Potter 2.0
Scott
Nadia (just because she's been in it the last 2 weeks and I can't think of anyone else)

Scott should go home.
Reply With Quote