Thread: American Idol 4
View Single Post
  #5  
Old 03-23-2005, 10:54 AM
LeslieAGD LeslieAGD is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Michigan
Posts: 7,867
Send a message via AIM to LeslieAGD
My two cents...

I think Simon's comments were pretty right on...
Here are my thoughts:

Anthony - Not good...bottom three

Carrie - Carrie's back! Great last tonight

Scott - Who is part of this guy's fanbase? I just don't get it. The vocals were okay, but he has the presence of a toaster oven.

Bo - Even when he sings a so-so song, he's still a star!

Nikko - He wins the "come back kid" award...nice job last night

Vonzell - Simon was right: this was the first time she stood out. Gold star for you, Vonzell.

Constantine - I'm not sure how he's picking his songs, but it's working for him. He's not trying to be like Bo...he's using his MT background a little more.

Nadia - Terrible...everything was terrible: the hair, the vocals, the song choice

Mikalah - meh...pack your bags, girl.

Anwar - I give him props for a gutsy song choice. He needed to do an up-tempo number, I just don't think this one worked for him.

Jessica - When she announced her song choice, I thought "ugh, this has been done practically every season." But she nailed it! WTG, Jessica.

Bottom Three Predictions: Mikalah, Anthony, and Scott
Next To Go Predicition: Mikalah

I hope that with the phone number fiasco, the right person still goes.
I would hate to see someone who deserves to stay leave due to confusion.
Here's an article about the mix-up:
http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/149...headlines=true
__________________
AGD
Reply With Quote