Thread: American Idol 4
View Single Post
  #15  
Old 03-02-2005, 11:35 AM
LeslieAGD LeslieAGD is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Michigan
Posts: 7,867
Send a message via AIM to LeslieAGD
To begin with, it sounded like they were having microphone problems because almost everyone was fading in and out.

Aloha - Awful...I didn't really think she was all that great last week either, but this week she just stunk.

Lindsey - Same as Aloha, they were both forgettable.

Jessica - I really like her for some reason. Even though she had a few off notes, it was overall a good performance and better than last week.

Mikalah - She can sing, but I don't like her at all. At least she was less annoying this week (like Simon said, it's because she didn't talk).

Celena - Another forgettable performance; I think it's her week to go.

Nadia - I just don't get the buzz around her (same as Fantasia, I didn't like her either). She has a good voice, but I don't see any real personality or anything that makes me interested in her voice or her style.

Amanda - I think she totally redeemed herself this week. She has the star look and personality. I hope she continues to improve and win over the voters.

Janay - Much better song choice for her, but doesn't connect with the audience/camera. She looks uncomfortable on stage. She *may* last one more week because she was featured so much early on, she improved, and a lot of her competition had blah performances.

Carrie - I didn't see what the big deal was about Carrie last week, but I did like her this week. I thought it was a good song choice and she had presence.

Vonzell - Not great at all, but she did enough to stay in this week. She might even make the top six girls if others continue to do badly or if the voters get sick of all the country-sounding girls.

My choices to go this week are:
Celena and Janay (alternate - Lindsey)
__________________
AGD
Reply With Quote