My thoughts on what makes a great website:
Needs great high quality pictures, crisp colors, and good content. Content needs to appeal to all potential audiences - Potential Members, Current Members, Alumnae, Other Greeks, Parents, Administrators, and the Community --- you never know who may be looking at it!
List your accomplishments prominently.
Have a password protected site for members and alumnae.
List of my favorite APhi Websites
Iota - University of Wisconsin-Madison
http://alphaphi.rso.wisc.edu/
Sigma - University of Washington
http://students.washington.edu/alphaphi/home.html
Tau - University of Oregon
http://gladstone.uoregon.edu/~alphaphi/
Psi - University of South Dakota
http://www.usd.edu/~aphi/
Omega - University of Texas
http://www.texasalphaphi.org/
Beta Nu deuteron - Duke University
http://www.duke.edu/web/aphi/index.html
Beta Omicron - Bowling Green State University
http://www.bgsu.edu/studentlife/greeks/alpha-phi/
Gamma Iota - Texas Tech University
http://www.techaphi.com/
Gamma Kappa - California State University - Long Beach
http://www.csulb.edu/greek/alphaphi/
Gamma Omicron - Drake University
www.drakealphaphi.org
Delta Mu - Purdue University
http://web.ics.purdue.edu/~alphaphi/
Zeta Beta – Loyola Marymount
http://aslmu.lmu.edu/alphaphi/
Zeta Pi - Case-Western Reserve University
http://home.cwru.edu/alphaphi/
Zeta Upsilon - Washington University
http://www.rescomp.wustl.edu/~aphi/
Eta Omicron - Virginia Tech
http://www.vtalphaphi.com
Iota Theta - Wilfrid Laurier
http://www.wluphis.com/
Iota Iota - The George Washington University
http://www.alphaphionline.com/iotaiota/