Hey ThetaPhiSkuttle!
I just checked out your website and there are some great gift ideas out there -
https://www.thetaphialpha.org/shop.php
make a frame with your creed - classy gift for years to come -- perhaps embellish it with sapphires and/or pearls --
http://www.thetaphialpha.org/who_symbols.php
corkboard decorated with a penquin - very cute mascot! could inscribe your family tree or something else meaningful on the back -- start a new family tradition!
penguin stickers from a craft store on anything glass i.e. fill it up with bath crystals, layered cookie mix, colored sand/salt
wooden penguin cut-out available at craft stores - decorate with your family tree
i am sure there are some great ideas for things that could be done with your other symbols like the compass and the white rose