My age: 28
His age: 42
Relationship status: Engaged, living together 2 years
What I gave: Cashmere scarf, book on Puerto Ricans in NYC, Jets sweatshirt, pj pants, DVD, men's facial & massage certifcate
what I received: 2 cashmere sweaters, cashmere scarf, Godivas, pj's, diamond stud earrings
How it worked out: Excellent, he loved all his stuff. I also love mine, though I have to return one sweater b/c he got the wrong size. I also have to admit - I got the diamonds in the stocking AFTER we were done with presents. I always say stockings are for silly, little things. So I WAS thinking a bit "Geez, love the stuff, but I sure spent way more than I needed to on him". Then I opened my new bling and felt a little bad...

  But that was cured when I put them on!!!